In the first
season of Mad Men, protagonist Don Draper crashes at the apartment of a
would-be girlfriend’s bunch of beatnik associates. Needless to say, they don’t hit it off. When asked how he sleeps at night, ad
executive Draper replies, “on a bed of money.”
Nevertheless,
they agree on one thing. They eventually
fall asleep after smoking a large quantity of pot. In the morning, they awaken to a police raid in
progress at a neighbor’s apartment.
Draper,
needing to report to work, straightens his tie and tugs on his suit coat to
pull out the wrinkles. As he opens the
front door, one of the beatniks anxiously objects, “You can’t go out there!”
Don pauses a
beat and says, “No, you can’t,“ and walks out, nodding at the policemen
in the hallway as he goes.
I was
reminded of this a couple of weeks ago as I boarded a plane for a brief
vacation in Mexico. Walking down the
jetway, I passed by a Customs and Border Protection agent. Suffice it to say, he was playing the
part. Body armor, M-4 carbine slung
across his chest, etc. Briefly looking
over at him, he gave me a slight nod.
Reflexively, I nodded back.
A fleeting
exchange to be sure, but telling all the same.
Like Don Draper, and unlike many other people, I can pass. I’m an average-looking middle-aged white male
who presents conventionally. In a sense,
I’m above suspicion. I’m just grateful no
one can detain me for my thoughts. Yet.
At least the
CBP agents were clearly identifiable. The news of late tells of law enforcement
officials unidentifiable by agency or uniform rounding up migrants and student
activists. Are they or aren’t they
actual cops?
The second coming
of Donald Trump has provoked a resurgence in militaristic cosplay. I first noticed the trend the first time
around during the lockdown phases of the pandemic. We were shown the spectacle of white men donning
tactical gear and brandishing weapons at urban civil rights protests and
setting up unauthorized roadblocks in rural locales asserting authority they
did not possess. The January 6th
insurrection appeared to be the climax of this nonsense which would simmer down
with the absence of Trump and his minions from Washington.
Wishful thinking. Shortly after the election, I was at the
airport waiting at the baggage carousel when I noticed a young man milling amongst
us. He was white, with a beard of
course. Otherwise dressed in civilian
attire, he was sporting a tactical vest.
He walked slowly, with a serious expression, thumbs hooked at the top of
his vest. I had no idea who the hell he
was or why he was there aside from being an arriving passenger, and I asked
myself if anyone else was even noticing this.
No one seemed to. It is common
enough lately that such sights scarcely raise an eyebrow.
Much as they
had during Trump 1.0, the real authorities have gotten in the act. News and phone footage showing what seemed to
be ICE agents abducting individuals in public are disturbingly frequent. The agents are generally clad in black or in
casual wear, their faces obscured with balaclavas or masks, and they are not
displaying badges or other markings identifying which agency they
represent. Homeland Security officials
defend the practice as protecting law enforcement personnel from being doxed.
Maybe, but
probably not. The intended effect is
performative intimidation made more ominous by ambiguity. It also looks cool, if you’re into that kind
of thing.
Homeland Security
secretary Kristi Noem is the poster girl for posturing as substitute for public
safety. We see her in tactical gear joining
Border Patrol agents on a raid. We watch
her posing in front of a packed cell of deportees at El Salvador’s supermax CECOT,
sporting a $50,000 Rolex no less. She parries
a question from U.S. Senator Alex Padilla at a press conference on the wholly unnecessary
federal intervention in the civil unrest in Los Angeles by siccing the Secret
Service on him.
The optics
are lost on her. Appearing before a
congressional committee recently, Rep. Bennie Thompson greeted her by thanking
her for her time amidst her busy schedule “of photo ops and costume changes.” Noem scarcely batted an eyelash.
As to be
expected, bad actors are getting in on the act.
You, too, can buy ICE merch online.
Young white males have taken to stationing themselves in Home Depot
parking lots wearing ICE jackets to scare off day laborers looking for
jobs. Even more troubling are reports of
midnight “raids” on immigrant households by people claiming to be government
agents. In one instance, a family was
told to hand over their phones and any cash in their possession. Contacting ICE and Homeland Security offices
afterward, the agencies denied knowledge.
The Trump
administration’s methods of ensuring law and order have encouraged vigilantism
and enabled common criminals to prey upon vulnerable people. You could reason that this is an intended
consequence. In the first category, we
have a small group of MAGA diehards who believe Trump possesses extralegal authority
and that anything they do on his behalf is justified. (I call this the deputization defense; several
J6 rioters believed Trump had “deputized” them to stop certification of the
2020 election results.) In the second category
are opportunistic crooks and garden variety assholes exploiting people who can’t
go to the police.
Authoritarians
are drawn to military and police regalia.
Perhaps even more so when the individual never served in the military or
law enforcement. (Consider Trump’s
fixation on parades.) At a certain
point, fantasy and reality blur. At a
certain point, the biggest Walter Mitty losers can delude themselves into
believing they’re the good guys simply by cultivating a look. Provoked by the violent
rhetoric emanating from Trump and his allies or internalizing a belief that
white men with guns are sheepdogs protecting home and hearth, and you have a recipe
for tragedy.
Policing in
a stable democracy must operate in the open.
Law enforcement should be clearly identifiable to the public they serve. If you’re acting legally, there is no reason
to hide who you are. Otherwise, you erode
public trust. When legitimate law
enforcement is indistinguishable from the LARPers you don’t believe your eyes anymore.
Perhaps this
moment will stimulate reform. We can set
guidelines for law enforcement agencies at the federal, state, and local levels
relating to how they present themselves to the public they serve. Place limitations on the sale and possession of
certain items such as body armor and certain kinds of lethal and non-lethal
weapons (though this probably wouldn’t pass constitutional muster in some
cases). Introduce stronger sanctions
against impersonating law enforcement and military personnel. Any of these would be a good start.
What we may
not be able to fix is a cultural toxicity that long predated Trump and
MAGA. They are a symptom or the latest
permutation of that ugliness. The only
road to improvement is through individual hearts and minds. And that is a task fit for Sisyphus.
©
2025 The Unassuming Scholar