Friday, October 2, 2015

Sylvia - II: Constructing a Symbol

The semiology of Sylvia Likens would make an interesting field of study for those so inclined.  When an individual’s life becomes a preoccupation for many people for whatever reason the meaning of that individual and her life can take on many different facets depending upon the beholder’s perspective and disposition.  Kate Millett devotes The Basement partly to the meaning of Sylvia’s ordeal within feminist discourse, but I have not encountered any in-depth discussion of Sylvia-as-symbol elsewhere.  For many of us touched by her story she represents victims of child abuse and neglect, though this is a crowded field.  For others, considerations of her suffering are an exercise in theodicy. 

There’s an element of mystery to Sylvia.  She is elusive.  We know much more about how Sylvia died than how she lived.  There are a few photographs, small tidbits from news articles, and the testimony of her parents and sister at the first trial.  There is little more to go on.

This lack points up how technology has transformed social relations over the past couple of decades.  People nowadays obsessively document their daily lives with even the most trivial events captured on camera phones and uploaded to social media.  Spontaneously recording anything and everything wasn’t practical with film cameras or even camcorders, and these technologies could be costly.  Similarly, very little personal information was readily available to the public pre-internet.  Piecing together the life story of someone who died long ago, aside from vital statistics or interviews with surviving friends and relatives, often means a reliance on artifacts.

In Sylvia’s case there are few artifacts in the public domain.  After her mother Betty died in 1998, found among her effects was a suitcase filled with letters, photos, and other keepsakes including childhood pictures of Sylvia.  A news article at the time dubbed it the “Suitcase of Sorrow.”   The suitcase presumably is still with the Likens family.  They have been understandably reticent to publicly discuss Sylvia or otherwise revisit her murder so we are unlikely to learn more about her. 

Here is what we know:

Sylvia Marie Likens was born on January 3, 1949, in Lebanon, Indiana, to Lester and Elizabeth (Grimes) Likens.  She died in Indianapolis on October 26, 1965, slightly more than two months shy of her 17th birthday.

She was the middle child of five.  Her older sister and brother, Dianna and Danny, were twins and were three years older than Sylvia.  Her younger sister and brother, Jenny and Benny, were also twins and a year younger.

Sylvia stood 5’ 4” and was of slender to average build.  She had either dark blonde or light brown hair.  Black and white photos (there are none in color) show she had dark eyes.  She was missing a front tooth from a childhood accident, so when she smiled it was with a closed mouth.

Her nickname was Cookie.

Sylvia enjoyed roller skating and dancing and singing and had a knack for drawing.  She liked The Beatles and Shirley Bassey.  She babysat and ironed laundry for pocket money and she would share her earnings with her mother.  She was an average student who probably wasn’t into academics but nevertheless understood the value of an education and had resolved to complete high school.

Her father and mother described Sylvia as quiet and dutiful.  She attended church and Sunday school regularly.  A prized possession was her bible, which she read often.

Perhaps the most striking thing, however, is that aside from Gertrude Baniszewski’s tales and the insinuations of defense attorneys at the first trial, nearly everyone who knew Sylvia had nothing but good to say about her.  Even the younger Baniszewski children said Sylvia was nice and helpful.   Sylvia undoubtedly had her faults, but the overall impression is that of a good, decent, and kind person. 

In the summer of 1965, Sylvia Likens was a happy and healthy teenager with much to look forward to.  You can get a sense of her essence from pictures taken at the time.  There is the iconic photograph of Sylvia with her upward gaze and wistful smile.  There is Sylvia posing with her mother; Betty’s expression is impassive while Sylvia’s exudes an ineffable sweetness that reaches out to the viewer across the years.  There’s a shot which appears to have been taken in a photo booth, with Sylvia in a plaid work shirt glancing sidelong at the camera.  Then there is the photograph taken in California on Easter Sunday 1965 in which Sylvia and Jenny are standing with three church friends after the service.  Sylvia, very much the young lady in an outfit replete with hat and white dress gloves, is on the left.  Taller than the other girls, she is bent slightly at the knees and is leaning forward a bit so as to fit into the picture.  The three friends are in the middle, with Jenny standing on the right. 

The paucity of information about her means that there are as many Sylvias as beholders.  Reading not only the Millett and Dean books but also the multitude of postings on the various websites devoted to her, it seems people feel compelled to project themselves on Sylvia.  You have your Sylvia, I have mine. 

The first people to project upon Sylvia were Gertrude and Paula Baniszewski.  For all intents and purposes Sylvia Likens had ceased to exist as a person once Gertrude confined her to the house, only to be endlessly redefined in other people’s imaginations.  Mother and daughter had an agenda, as we would now say.  Gertrude and Paula were not paragons of chastity—Gertrude had just broken off a relationship with a man fourteen years her junior after having his baby and miscarrying another while Paula was pregnant after a fling with a married man.  And yet they proclaimed themselves upright Christians just the same.  To square the circle, as it were, they ascribed their sins to their teenage boarder with terrifying results.  Their Sylvia was a dirty, promiscuous liar and thief unworthy of life let alone of sharing their home.

Then there are the literary Sylvias.  John Dean portrays Sylvia as an unlucky girl from the wrong side of the tracks, a “Cinderella for the prince who never showed.”  For Kate Millett, Sylvia is a transcendent victim of patriarchy.  These accounts are the gateway, if you will, to that portion of Sylvia’s world we can access.  They are the springboard for others to search for understanding.

It’s interesting to read the various online discussion threads devoted to Sylvia.  The posters are identified by age and gender, many of whom are under twenty.  While most of the threads seriously discuss aspects of the Likens murder and the motivations of the individuals involved, some are endearingly whimsical as well.  What was Sylvia’s favorite color?  Her favorite season?  Which Beatle was her favorite?  Would she like today’s music?  How would she like today’s social media?  What would she have done with her life had she hadn’t died young?  (Some guesses are fanciful—pop music diva.  Others are more prosaic—schoolteacher.)  To her younger devotees, Sylvia is a virtual BFF from another time.

Perhaps this isn’t such a bad thing if it makes us more empathetic.  There are lots of people who feel a need to connect with Sylvia in some way.  There are occasional posters on the message boards who say they knew Sylvia while she was alive, claims which are usually debunked.  Such claims of having known Sylvia or the Likens family do not seem to be a recent phenomenon.  Kate Millett wrote of a speaking engagement in Florida in the mid-1970s during which she mentioned in passing that she was beginning work on the book which eventually became The Basement.   After the talk, Millett was approached by a young woman who said she had gone to school with Sylvia in the fall of 1965.  Millett made time to chat with the woman about her memories of Sylvia.  Following the discussion Millett wondered how much of the woman’s story was true.  One does detect a fabulist streak in these claims of familiarity.  Better to think idly about alternative endings to Sylvia’s story than to stir up trouble with phony claims of knowledge.

As interesting as speculating on what might have been can be, the luckiest thing that could have happened to Sylvia Likens would have been obscurity.  Had she not met up with Gertrude Baniszewski she would have lived her life quietly and safely within her circle of family and friends.  In this alternate telling of Sylvia’s story she would finish school, get married, and start a family since few young people of limited means went on to further schooling in those days.  If she was fortunate the marriage would last.  She was said to have a rapport with younger children, and I like to think she would have been a good mom.  If she worked outside the home it would likely be in a service occupation such as waitress, cashier, or nurse’s aide.  By now, she would be retired and enjoying her grandchildren.  I am certain she would have been happy with such a life, or at least content.

Life takes interesting twists and turns, though.  I am sure Sylvia would have had many opportunities to find happiness and personal fulfillment.   It’s a pity she never had the chance.



© 2015 The Unassuming Scholar

Sunday, September 27, 2015

Sylvia



A little over sixteen years ago, about the span of time Sylvia Marie Likens graced this world, I suddenly found myself with a lot of time on my hands.

I was in the hospital having survived a near-fatal accident which left me permanently disabled and irrevocably altered my life’s trajectory.  About midway through a two month stay, I was moved from the ICU to a room on the surgical ward.  The days dragged by.  One can only sleep so long or watch so much TV, so I went looking for reading material besides the newspaper and months-old magazines.  Fortunately, this hospital had a small branch of the local public library on the grounds.  As soon as I was able to get around on my own I paid a visit, wheeling myself over to the true crime shelf.

Browsing the stacks I came across a book titled The Basement.  Its subject was the 1965 torture murder of Sylvia Likens, a crime I had never heard of.  At first glance it looked like a mildly interesting damsel-in-distress story about an obscure murder from years ago.  What caught my attention was that the book’s author was Kate Millett.  I knew of Millett mostly from excerpts of Sexual Politics assigned in a college sociology class.  A look at the jacket blurb confirmed it was indeed the same Ms. Millett.  Curious as to why a feminist theorist would write a crime book and finding it marginally more interesting than the other titles on offer I checked it out with lukewarm enthusiasm and took it back to my room.

I got through The Basement in a couple of days.  I was not prepared for what I read.  The book intersperses the factual narrative of the Sylvia Likens murder with the fictionalized internal monologues of both victim and victimizers.  I returned the book to the library as soon as I finished.  I did not want it near me, and I would not read The Basement again until this past summer.  It left me deeply unsettled and in a low mood, a feeling which stayed with me for days.  I had a room to myself and at night I would stare at the ceiling in the dark unable to get the mental images to go away.  It came to the point where I would call the duty nurse claiming I was experiencing breakthrough pain when in fact I wanted the mental respite morphine would afford me.

The bad thoughts eventually subsided, replaced by more mundane concerns among the tedium of clinic appointments and occupational therapy sessions.  But for years, often apropos of nothing I can figure, persistent thoughts of Sylvia have recurred from time to time.  It becomes a preoccupation where for weeks or sometimes even months I feel driven to refresh my knowledge of the case and to add to it whenever possible.    

I can’t really explain my emotional investment in the Likens case, or why it resonates with me.  I’m not overly fond of kids, least of all the adolescent subspecies.  Nor am I particularly sensitive.  And yet, sometimes when I revisit the story after a long time the sadness it inspires can bring me to the edge of tears. 

Perhaps a brief introduction is in order, if you are unfamiliar with the facts.  Sylvia Likens was a sixteen year old girl living in Indianapolis in the summer of 1965.  Sylvia’s parents, who worked as concessionaires with a traveling carnival, needed to board their children while on the summer fair circuit.  Sylvia and her fifteen year old sister Jenny were left in the care of Gertrude Baniszewski, a gaunt, asthmatic woman who lived with her seven children, the youngest only a year old, in a ramshackle Eastside house.  Mrs. Baniszewski agreed to provide room and board for the girls for $20 a week. 

Over the ensuing sixteen weeks what began as an uneventful sojourn in the Baniszewski home became a waking nightmare.  Meals were skimpy.  Beds were shared.  Gertrude was a harsh disciplinarian who would lash out with little warning.  Two weeks into the sisters' stay she slapped Jenny, a polio victim who wore a leg brace, because the first $20 weekly payment hadn’t arrived from their parents on time.  (It came a day or two later.  Subsequent payments arrived as scheduled.) 

Gertrude’s ire soon focused on Sylvia.  The physical and emotional abuse intensified over the ensuing weeks.  The Baniszewski kids, along with a few from the neighborhood who hung around the Baniszewski home, joined in as a sort of pastime.  After Sylvia died on October 26th, the 113th day of her stay with the Baniszewski family, the coroner found a malnourished body, badly bruised, covered in an estimated 150 cigarette burns, with scalded and scraped patches of skin and a suppurating sore on her head.  Much of her hair had been roughly cut away.  Her genitals were bruised and swollen (from repeated kicks to the groin administered by Gertrude as it turned out).

In addition to her other injuries Sylvia had been branded on the abdomen with the words, “I’m a prostitute and proud of it!”  Above the tattoo was a burn mark in a figure 3.  To cope with the pain, Sylvia had chewed her lips raw and broken back her fingernails on the concrete floor of the basement where she had been confined for the previous two weeks.  (Sylvia had become incontinent from the constant abuse and was no longer allowed to live upstairs with the rest of the household.)  The coup de grace, however, came from repeated blows to the head which caused the brain hemorrhage that ultimately killed her. 

Gertrude told police Sylvia had disappeared for several days, returning the previous night half naked, branded, and clutching a handwritten note.  The note said she had gone off with a group of boys who then abused and abandoned her.  Gertrude said she and her family had ministered to Sylvia the best they could, but it wasn’t enough.  Daughter Stephanie said she had tried to resuscitate Sylvia while sending neighbor boy Ricky Hobbs to phone for help but Sylvia died before it could arrive. 

Jenny at first stuck to the story offered up by Gertrude, then told a police officer she would tell them everything if he would get her away from the Baniszewskis.  By the end of the evening Indianapolis police had arrested Gertrude and Ricky Hobbs on a preliminary charge of first-degree murder, formalized a few weeks later by a grand jury.  The three eldest Baniszewski children—Paula, Stephanie, and Johnny, as well as Stephanie’s boyfriend Coy Hubbard—were held initially on delinquency charges until indicted by a grand jury for first-degree murder.  Several other neighbor children who were hangers on at the Baniszewski house were also arrested and subsequently charged with injury to person.

Eventually, Gertrude, Paula, Johnny, Coy, and Ricky were tried together.  The prosecution delayed Stephanie’s trial presumably in exchange for her testimony; the charges against her were ultimately dropped as were the charges against the other children initially taken into custody. 

The trial itself was a lurid affair, with spectators vying for courtroom seats and the newspapers providing detailed daily coverage.  The fact the defendants were being tried together made the testimony confusing at times.  Gertrude blamed the kids for Sylvia’s death.  The kids blamed Gertrude.  Jenny Likens’ testimony, among the lengthier in the trial record if not the lengthiest, provided the most reliable details of her sister’s ordeal the previous autumn.  In addition to her visible wounds, Sylvia was systematically dehumanized by Gertrude and company.  The humiliations included Gertrude forcing Sylvia to undress and penetrate herself with an empty Pepsi bottle in front of the rest of the household on two occasions and making Sylvia drink urine and eat feces.  The handwritten note Sylvia supposedly carried with her when she returned after her purported absence from the Baniszewski home, along  with a second note handed by Gertrude to police were actually dictated to Sylvia by Gertrude as part of an abandoned plan to dump Sylvia in the woods.

And so forth.  Gertrude pled temporary insanity to no avail.  She was convicted of first degree murder.  Although the prosecution sought the death penalty, she was sentenced to life in prison.  Paula was convicted of second-degree murder and also drew a life sentence.  Johnny, Coy, and Ricky each was convicted of voluntary manslaughter and sentenced to up to 21 years in prison.  Each served two years and was released on parole.  Ricky died of cancer in 1972 at age 21.

Citing undue publicity in the run up to the 1966 trial, the Indiana Supreme Court overturned Gertrude and Paula’s convictions.   Granted a change of venue, Gertrude was retried in 1971, convicted, and sentenced again to life imprisonment.  Paula pled guilty to voluntary manslaughter rather than go to trial and was paroled in 1973.

Gertrude was by all accounts a model prisoner and a mother figure to the younger inmates.  She was paroled in 1985 amidst public outrage.  She changed her name, moved to Iowa, and died of lung cancer in 1990.

It took me nearly 1,000 words to describe the essential facts of the Likens murder, and that was a basic summary.  I’ve read about it countless times, and I’m still dumbfounded by the vicious pack mentality which drove Sylvia’s tormentors.  Equally baffling was the apathy of the many adult bystanders who, while they might not have known everything that was going on, surely knew enough and could have stepped in to stop the abuse or at least gotten in touch with the authorities.

Sylvia and Jenny were in contact with a number of adults during the period in question.  Their parents visited the Baniszewski home several times and didn’t notice anything amiss.  Sylvia attended school from September until the first week of October.  A neighbor woman dropped by on two occasions and noticed Sylvia’s injuries and actually witnessed Paula assaulting Sylvia during her first visit.  She did and said nothing.  The family’s pastor and a public health nurse visited at various times and were told by Gertrude that Sylvia had become unmanageable.  The pastor did not insist on seeing Sylvia, and the nurse was told she was in juvenile detention.  Each accepted Gertrude’s stories and neither thought nothing more of it until after Sylvia was dead and beyond help.  Perhaps most vexingly of all, Jenny never spoke to anyone about her sister’s mistreatment until after it was too late.

That’s it, as succinct as I can make it within the confines of a blog post.  As I wrote earlier I’ve been at a loss to explain my preoccupation with a person whose existence ended before mine began, someone I could never have known, so I will give it a try.  I believe it is because when I first read of Sylvia I was very sick as well as physically and emotionally isolated.  I needed to feel sympathy for another human being.  I needed a break from feeling sorry for myself.  How could I feel bitter over my condition when I had already lived twice as long as Sylvia by that point and had experienced so much of life that she never had a chance to live?  Sylvia’s story resonated with me because I have an affinity for people who have endured great adversity, particularly those who have lived through serious illnesses or traumas.  I believe Sylvia possessed an uncommon inner strength which sustained her until her body finally gave out, a strength which is truly worthy of admiration.

If I had to choose another reason why I’ve remained partial to Sylvia it would be that my late mother was a Gertrude, a toxic, manipulative, and destructive person.  She differed from Gertrude only in the magnitude of her sins.  I also grew up in a similar milieu as the Likens, Baniszewskis, and the other kids involved (though I don’t remember anyone ever using the word “milieu” outside of school…or at school for that matter).  My family was always financially strapped due to my mother’s instability and irresponsible behavior.  For a time we even lived in a house without a stove, just like the Baniszewskis.  Like them we heated our meals on a hotplate.  And as far as discipline was concerned: I came of age in the early 1980s, when child abuse was only beginning to become a public issue.   Parents still pretty much had carte blanche when it came to how they corrected their kids.

But there’s even more to it for me.  Beyond identifying on a personal level, I find the setting of the Likens murder at odds with how we portray the Midwest in popular culture.  You know the stereotype: Norman Rockwell country, populated by hardworking, salt of the earth folks.  You expect strange stuff to go on in New York City and Los Angeles, not in places like Indianapolis.   Indiana in 1965 must have seemed like a fine, safe place to raise your kids.  (Then again, maybe I’ve read too many Jean Shepherd stories.)

The truth is that Indiana, and the Midwest itself, has its own dark side.  Indiana was a hotbed for the Ku Klux Klan in the 1920s.  (The state Grand Dragon, D. C. Stephenson, was convicted of kidnapping and raping an object of his affections who then took her own life.)  The Rev. Jim Jones founded the first incarnation of Peoples Temple in Indianapolis before decamping first to California and subsequently to Guyana.  In the years following Sylvia Likens’ death Indiana has seen its share of brutality, including the 1971 LaSalle Street massacre, the unsolved serial murders of gay men in late 1970s Indianapolis, and the 1992 killing of Shanda Sharer in Madison.  The juxtaposition of innocence and evil is hard for me to pass up.

Apparently I’m not alone.  In the years since I first read The Basement there has been a resurgence of interest in Sylvia Likens.  Indianapolis Star reporter John Dean’s account of the murder and first trial, House of Evil, out of print for decades, was reissued several years ago.  The case has also inspired two movies, The Girl Next Door (a treatment of a novel based on Sylvia’s murder) and An American Crime (about the case itself).  What surprised me most is how people have used cyberspace to contribute to public knowledge concerning the murder and its aftermath.  A website dedicated to Sylvia, www.sylvialikens.com, has been up for several years.  The site is exceptionally well curated and contains such treasures as transcripts from the first trial, rare photographs and news clippings, and a message board where Sylvia’s devotees can congregate.  It is clearly a labor of love. 

So, there it is.  I will follow up with a few posts with my thoughts on the Likens case in the hope that doing so will get Sylvia out of my system for a little while, though I know she will be back soon enough.



© 2015 The Unassuming Scholar

Friday, September 25, 2015

For Whom the Bell Tolls

I’m not sure why I stopped to look.  The bulletin board in the Verdant Fields Community College faculty workroom is in an awkward location next to the door, so it’s easy to miss.  Whatever the reason, one item grabbed my attention.

It was a notice that Chuck Barnes, a longtime adjunct sociology instructor and evening coordinator for the part-time faculty support center, had died last week.  He passed away of a heart attack in his living room recliner, his Golden Retriever dozing at his feet.  He was 74 years old.

I’d had a long standing though casual friendship with Chuck over the years, stopping by the support center after my Thursday evening classes to hang out, drink coffee, and swap stories.  Chuck, a grizzled retired cop, had a lot of them.  He never disappointed.  Our Thursday night talks were one of the highlights of my week.

Returning for classes this fall, I learned that the college had ended the evening coordinator program and that the faculty support center would henceforth close at 7:00.  Chuck, whose department had declined to offer him any classes the previous year after over forty years of teaching, was abruptly and unceremoniously “retired.”

It wasn’t because he was a substandard employee.  Far from it; he had the universal esteem of his colleagues.  It wasn’t that he was a bad teacher; generations of students remember him fondly.  It did not matter.  He no longer fit the administration’s agenda, and so he was gone.  

Discussing Chuck’s passing with Amanda, the support center’s administrative assistant, I learned that he had been depressed over having had lost his position.  Chuck loved the give and take of the classroom, and being deprived of it was hard for him.  Losing his job as coordinator hit him just as badly.  It might have been nice to have someone to lean on, but his wife had died three years ago.  His son and daughter-in-law would check in on him from time to time, but most days his dog was his main company.  He had hobbies.  He was a motorcycle aficionado, but that is hardly sufficient to fill the days.  He was pleased with his new Cadillac, but where would he go?

Finding out about Chuck’s death made me think again of Margaret Mary Vojtko.  Vojtko, the subject of my last post, was the Duquesne adjunct professor who died in dire poverty after having had her teaching schedule cut back.  I know the all rationales for adjunct schedule cutbacks.  Enrollment is down.  We’re dealing with budget cuts.  The state legislature and the Board of Regents want more sections taught by tenured professors, though they won’t vote for any new tenure-track hires.  Yes, I understand.  But it’s funny that we haven’t seen any administration positions cut.  In fact, VFCC is hiring additional administrators.

Chuck’s dying was a premonition of things to come.  It has not been a banner week for The Scholar.  Daniel, my department chair, informed me by email yesterday that after seven years of teaching the maximum allowed three sections of my course each semester that I would be pulled back to two for the spring.  There was a vague promise (if you can call it that) that if enrollment allowed he would offer me a third, but I’m not hanging my hat on it.  Later in the afternoon I got a heads-up, again by email, from my department chair at Snowflake College that my spring schedule may be further cut there as well.

Living where I do I don’t have a lot of teaching employment options.  It’s Snowflake and VFCC or I’m on the breadline.  Like Chuck, teaching for me is the finest, noblest thing I have ever done.  Like Chuck, I am better than good at it.  Like Chuck, I’m facing career oblivion through no fault of my own.  I’ve been planning for an early retirement for a long time, but that assumes I’ll have a job in the meantime.  For the first time since I began my career I am genuinely worried for my future, not just in the classroom but for my life itself.  I think Chuck passed away because he had lost his purpose in this world.   For me this would be the worst possible thing I could ever face.
  
Amanda informed me that there would be memorial service for Chuck next month.  The police department will provide an honor guard.  I’m sure the service will be well-attended by the many people whose lives he touched.

I wonder if any of VFCC’s administrators will be there.



© 2015 The Unassuming Scholar

Tuesday, September 1, 2015

Margaret Mary Vojtko (1930-2013)

Margaret Mary Vojtko passed away two years ago today.

An adjunct professor of French at Duquesne University, Vojtko became a symbol for the abuses and indignities, great and small, experienced by part-time faculty. 



Vojtko was 83 years old, sick with cancer, and impoverished when she died.  Duquesne had reduced her course load to a single class per semester after twenty-five years of service before dismissing her outright.  She had been caught sleeping in her office because she couldn’t afford to heat her home due to the costs of her cancer treatment.  She was fired and escorted off campus by the police.  No severance pay, no retirement benefits.  A clean break, at least for Duquesne.

It wasn’t cancer that killed Vojtko, at least not directly.  A heart attack felled her on an August morning after she had received a letter from Adult Protective Services.  APS had received an anonymous tip which said Vojtko could not adequately care for herself.  If she didn’t attend a mandatory meeting with a social worker her case would be referred to a judge.  She was found prostrate on her front lawn.  She died in hospital two weeks later.

Obscure in life, Margaret Mary Vojtko became a cause cĂ©lèbre after her death.  Daniel Kovalic described Vojtko’s plight in an article devoted to Vojtko titled “Death of an Adjunct.”  The article was widely circulated in academic circles and while there was much outrage expressed nothing has changed.

Adjuncts are a disenfranchised class, with little control over work assignments or working conditions.  It is mind-boggling that a woman who should have retired with a pension and healthcare benefits years earlier was still hustling for class assignments each semester and working nights in a restaurant to make ends meet.  Margaret Mary Vojtko was erudite, fluent in five languages.  The only explanation for her perseverance is a love of craft. 

An obituary noted she had begun a doctoral program in medieval French literature but that she never completed her dissertation.  A PhD is no guarantee of tenure-track employment, but it is a prerequisite even at community colleges where faculty generally don’t engage in research.  Vojtko plugged away semester after semester, year after year until she finally gave out.  She surely never anticipated her fate.

I can see how easily such a thing can happen.  During my first semester of graduate school a decade and a half ago, the professor leading one of my seminars invited us students out for a drink one evening.  The prof and I got into a discussion about careers in academia.  Being new I naively assumed that there was a linear path from graduate school to teaching and research.  The professor, himself a recent product of a prestigious graduate program, laughed cynically when I said as much.  He then told me what happened to most doctoral students.  He said most end up as cheap academic labor whose fellowships are renewed each year for the unstated purpose of ensuring the university has instructors for its lower division courses.  These graduate students become bogged down in their programs, make slow or no progress, and they eventually drop out or are dropped by their graduate advisors.  The nonstarters then drift into contingent faculty jobs at universities and community colleges if they stay in academia at all.

Listening to this I nodded and laughed inwardly and told myself I would never be one of those losers.  And yet, that’s pretty much what happened with me.  Four years into a six-year teaching fellowship I lost my funding due to budget cuts.  Although I was progressing well in my program I could not afford to pay my tuition out of pocket, so I abandoned graduate school and with it any hope of a tenure track position.  I enjoyed teaching so I stuck with it despite the pitfalls of being an adjunct.

I wonder if this is really what happened with Margaret Mary Vojtko.  I shudder at the thought of her end befalling anyone else.  It is as if we have come full circle to a postindustrial era of laissez-faire capitalism.  For Vojtko, a staunch supporter of labor unions whose father organized steelworkers in the 1930s, it had become a matter of every individual for themselves against the immovable object that is management.  I’ve experienced this myself but not for such desperate stakes. 

The shame of it all is that the regrets came only after the circumstances of Vojtko’s death became widely known.  I cannot see that any of the lessons of her case have been applied by higher education’s institutional leaders.  Perhaps they are counting on the public’s short memory.  They know they can.

They can, that is, until the next Mary Margaret Vojtko happens.


© 2015 The Unassuming Scholar


Friday, August 28, 2015

Vicious Circle

I had an epiphany today.  It occurred to me that as an adjunct professor I actually have something in common with corporate CEOs: Employment and pay aren’t necessarily tied to job performance.

The first week of classes went very well.  Three sections full and about half a dozen students seeking to add each of the other two.  I met with my last section of the week yesterday afternoon and went to my office to catch up on administrative work.  Opening my email I saw that the top message was from Matt, my department chair at Snowflake College.  The subject was simply titled “spring” [sic].

The message wasn’t what I expected to read.

From: Matt (chair@snowflake.edu)
Sent: Thursday, August 27, 2015 1:50 PM
To: Unassuming Scholar (scholar@snowflake.edu)
Subject: spring

Hello,

I hope that all is going well.  I am working on the schedule for next semester and was wondering which Quartz City section you prefer - day or night.

Things had been going well—until now.  As happens so often when I get messages from administrators and chairs my heart leaped into my throat. 

Here’s a little background so you will understand my problem.  I teach at two institutions on three different campuses.  Snowflake is a multi-campus institution covering a large geographical area.  I live more than eighty miles from the main campus where Matt and the other profs in my department work.  For the last several years I have been the sole instructor in my subject at my “home” campus in Treetop, a resort town in the mountains, and at the Quartz City campus in the foothills roughly sixty miles away.

Although I am the least senior part-timer in my department, even after nearly a decade of employment, no one based at the main campus is willing to make the long drive into the hills to take sections at Quartz City and Treetop thus giving me a de facto monopoly.

Or so I thought.

From: Unassuming Scholar (scholar@snowflake.edu)
Sent: Thursday, August 27, 2015 2:01 PM
To: Matt (chair@snowflake.edu)
Subject: Re: spring

Hello Matt...Is there someone else teaching at Quartz City next semester?

The answer came a few minutes later:

From: Matt (chair@snowflake.edu)
Sent: Thursday, August 27, 2015 2:05 PM
To: Unassuming Scholar (scholar@snowflake.edu)
Subject: Re: spring

We are in the process of looking at adding some part time faculty and Quartz City would be an option.  In the past we have had two folks up the hill, which gives us some safety should we lose and instructor and it gives students so [sic] diversity.

I was puzzled and slightly disturbed by that last comment.  I told myself that he meant giving students a choice of instructor rather than being stuck with just me but it didn’t help.

I pondered my options, staring at the computer screen momentarily paralyzed with anxiety.  I remembered a remark the Quartz City campus executive dean (not to be confused with the Executive Dean from Hell at the Treetop campus) made last week during a faculty in-service meeting.  She said that the demographics of the Quartz City area were changing and that Quartz City was transitioning from a predominantly evening campus to a day campus. 

I replied:

From: Unassuming Scholar (scholar@snowflake.edu)
Sent: Thursday, August 27, 2015 2:27 PM
To: Matt (chair@snowflake.edu)
Subject: Re: spring

I understand the reasoning, though I clearly would prefer both QC sections.  Treetop has me tentatively scheduled for TR 4:00-5:20, which means it probably won't make enrollment.

If I have to make a choice the TR 12:30-1:50 section would be the best fit.

The next volley landed in my inbox shortly thereafter:

From: Matt (chair@snowflake.edu)
Sent: Thursday, August 27, 2015 2:50 PM
To: Unassuming Scholar (scholar@snowflake.edu)
Subject: Re: spring

Hi,

Interesting.  Patty sent a rollover indicating that it was taught 2:30-3:50 last Spring.  I imagine that they will cling to that section (regardless of the time) to the bitter end in Spring - they do not want to lose course offerings entirely.

We will list the night course as staff and see what develops; we might need you to take it on in the end.  It all depends.  But I hope to clear up the uncertainty as soon as possible.

Best wishes

Yep, clearing up the uncertainty would be pretty frickin’ great.  Going over the message a second time I found myself wondering about Matt’s odd practice of omitting his correspondent’s name from the salutation and his own from the closing.  I was also confused by the lack of precision.  Was “it” a section at Quartz City or Treetop?  “It” didn’t match the schedule I’d been on at either campus any time lately.  The Executive Dean from Hell’s administrative assistant at Treetop is named Patti, so maybe that’s the campus he meant.

From: Unassuming Scholar (scholar@snowflake.edu)
Sent: Thursday, August 27, 2015 3:01 PM
To: Matt (chair@snowflake.edu)
Subject: Re: spring

Hi Matt,

Last spring I taught a Monday evening section at Treetop.  Believe it or not, that class filled and ran a wait list.  This semester, nothing.   I don't know if it's scheduling or just the fickle nature of student demand on a small campus.

If you are referring to QC, all the TR afternoon sections I've taught there from Fall 2012 forward have met at 12:30.

I'll try to keep my dance card open Weds. evenings just in case.

Thanks,

Unassuming Scholar

I sat slumped in my desk chair, utterly deflated.  It’s been a day and I still feel this way. 

I honestly don’t understand why the department chair wants to scale back my workload.  For all the heartburn I’ve had with Treetop’s EDFH, my department has been great to work with.  Unlike Verdant Fields, my other institution, adjuncts participate in scheduled department meetings and our input is solicited on student learning outcomes for each course we offer, whether our institutional objectives are being met, best teaching practices, etc.  It’s all very collegial and an exception to the norm for part-timers elsewhere.  Until yesterday I honestly (and I guess naively) believed I was a valued member of the team.

It can’t be my performance.  It just can’t.  My last classroom evaluation was a year ago and it went swimmingly.  Matt solicited the students’ input while I was out of the room, which was provided along with the very positive write up of the visit.  Not a single negative comment from the class.  I even got an “attaboy” note from our associate dean.

That’s why the decision hurts so much.  I know I complain a lot in these pages about lazy, entitled students and self-interested administrators but I thoroughly enjoy the act of teaching.  Sure, I have my off days like anyone.  But when I’m in the “zone,” when the students are engaged by what I’m saying and every single one of them is hanging on my every word, it’s the best feeling in the world.  It is the closest experience I have to love in my life and it is painful to me when any of it is taken away.

Now I’m on tenterhooks awaiting my fate.  Treetop will continue to toy with me, and Snowflake’s part-time seniority system is the only thing keeping me on staff.  Not that EDFT wouldn’t jump at the chance to show me the door.  The funny thing is that she doesn’t know me well even though she’s been in her position for nearly seven years.  I got on great with her predecessor, but EDFH and I have never even had a proper conversation.   The only conclusion I’ve come to is she formed an immediate and irrational dislike of me at first sight.  One factor in her dislike is that I think my appearance and manner clash with her idiosyncratic vision for the campus.  The executive deanship at Treetop campus is a platform for EDFH’s vanity and she wants nothing or no one to contradict her viewpoint.  Unless I can outlast her, which I doubt, I’m basically screwed.

I still haven’t heard about spring term from Daniel, my department chair at Verdant Fields Community College which is located in a neighboring state 35 miles from Treetop.  The pay at VFCC is uniformly lousy with no seniority or benefits.  But Daniel has consistently assigned me the maximum allowable three sections per semester for years.  (Another plus of VFCC is that the support staff in every single office and department I’ve encountered have been without fail friendly and helpful toward part-timers.)  But Daniel warned me over the summer that he might not be able to offer me three sections for spring.  Our former academic dean is from our department and he returned to the classroom this year, reducing the number of sections available for part-time faculty.  That reasoning I can understand even though I still wish to have three sections.  Besides, the ex-dean is an established authority in his field…and he is a great guy to boot.

Meanwhile I’m trying to calm my nerves.  I worked with a much smaller teaching load for years and still got by financially.  My oldest son is an adult now and I’m not paying support, which eases some of my money problems.  I’ve built up my savings the last two years.  I tell myself it could be worse.

And that is the problem, particularly at Snowflake.  A smaller load slows my accrual of further seniority and salary step increases.  Snowflake faculty participate in our state’s public school teacher retirement fund which requires the equivalent of five years’ full-time employment to vest.  Fewer classes mean I have to work more years to be eligible for retirement.  (By contrast VFCC is in a Right-to-Work state.  It’s “retirement” system consists of mandatory contributions to a 457 fund.)

I do not know how much longer I can keep at this.  I have a small pension from my earlier career but the income stream doesn’t cover even my modest lifestyle.  My younger son, to whom I am obliged to pay a monthly allowance while attending college, turns 22 in a little more than five years ending my financial responsibility for my family.  I had hoped to have enough money put together by then to retire from teaching and moving to an expat-friendly country such as Mexico or Belize to live.

That looks much less likely now.  Course load reductions can send a part-timer into a vicious spiral.  As his teaching income shrinks, the adjunct has to look for supplemental income or give up teaching altogether to stay afloat.  The thought of leaving the classroom is hateful to me.   It is an integral part of my identity, and I am too old to begin again at something else.  I don’t want to do anything else.  This is my calling.

If only the people I work for understood this.  Unfortunately for me I am only another wheel in the machine to them.   

I guess that’s what I am.  Expendable.

I think I will crawl into a bottle of bourbon this weekend.  There doesn’t seem to be much else left to do.



© 2015 The Unassuming Scholar 

Tuesday, August 25, 2015

A New Generation in the Workplace

Yeah, I know this has been around a while.  I just needed to cheer myself up during the first week of classes.


Enjoy.



Friday, August 21, 2015

Face Blind

The other day I stopped by a deli to pick up dinner.  As I approached the counter the young woman behind it smiled broadly and greeted me as if she knew me.

“Oh my gosh, how are you?”

“U-h-h-h-h… hi?”

After a split second it occurred to me that she did look familiar, but I still couldn’t place her.  She was quick to fill me in.

“It’s Lindsay,” she said helpfully.  “I took your class last fall.”

Oh, right.  “Hi.  Sorry about that, I didn’t recognize you without your glasses.”

These little embarrassments are happening with me more frequently lately.   I’m glad that the former students who recognize me seem pleased to see me, but I’ve had hundreds of them over the last ten years or so and I’m not capable of recalling all of them as much as I would like to.

Many instructors I work with are better at this than I.  I’m not sure how they do it.  I pride myself at learning the names of every student enrolled in my classes within the first month of the semester, but once grades are in the information magically vanishes.  I do remember a few of the standouts from over the years, good and bad, but most are lost to my memory.

This doesn’t bother me ordinarily, at least until I encounter the next student who remembers me better than I remember him or her.  I still feel rather badly about a run-in I had a few weeks ago on the last day of spring semester.  I was walking with colleagues after class on our way to grab a well-earned drink.  As we walked past a couple of students lounging on the grass next to the quad's artificial pond one of them waved and called out, “Hey, Mr. Scholar!” 

I stopped.  She seemed vaguely familiar, but so do half the students on campus. 

“Remember me?”  She was smiling expectantly.  God, this was going to be awkward.

“Sure!”  I paused a beat hoping she would take the hint and remind me how I should recollect her.

“I was in your Wednesday night class a while back, remember?”  No, not really.

Suddenly I was able to place her.  Not her name, but that of her boyfriend who took the class with her.  “Ah, right, you’re Dylan’s…friend.”

The girl pouted, “You remember Dylan’s name but not mine?”  She actually looked hurt.

I felt my face redden slightly.  “Sorry," I stammered.  "I’ve had so many students in so many places for such a long time.  I try, but I can’t remember everyone.”  Seeing my friends getting away from me I sheepishly excused myself and rushed to catch up.

“Alyssa!” the young lady’s voice called after me.  “My name’s Alyssa!”

I turned.  “Take care, Alyssa!” I called back.

Most encounters aren’t this bad.  I try to remember their names when I recognize their faces and play along gamely when I don’t.

It’s funny, though.  When I taught my first course as an instructor of record (that is, without the training wheels of a tenure-track professor’s supervision), I thought it would be like first love.  I vowed never to forget my students’ names, particularly when they were such a wonderful group who cheerfully forgave all my rookie fumbles that semester.

Seven years later during commencement one of the students walking the stage looked awfully familiar.  As usual, I couldn’t place him at first.  He was a stocky, nondescript looking boy with a close haircut.  Then it struck me.  He had been a student in my very first class.  Not a very good one it turned out; checking my records the kid finished with a D.  No wonder it took him seven years to complete a two-year degree.  Seeing him made me think about that first class, and it dawned on me that I could not recall a single name of any of its students.  So much for first love.

I give it my best effort, but I as get older my memory becomes less reliable.  But I do experience the occasional victory.

Walking out the door of the deli, wrapped sandwich in hand, I bumped into a young man I recognized.

“Hi…Trevor,” I said tentatively.

I must have gotten it right, because the young man smiled and said, “How’s it goin’, Mr. Scholar?”

I walked out to my car feeling quite pleased with myself.


© 2015 The Unassuming Scholar