Showing posts with label Snowflake College. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Snowflake College. Show all posts

Friday, August 25, 2017

Once More into the Breach

It’s the week before classes begin and I’m in the faculty workroom at my “other” college, Verdant Fields, when my colleague Jesse shuffles in looking just a little depressed.

Actually, he looked thoroughly, disconcertingly abject.  Jesse is normally an outgoing, even charismatic guy.  His students love him, and last spring he received the college’s annual excellence in teaching award.  Trying to engage Jesse, I ask about his summer. 

Shrugging, he tells me he taught a summer class.  He mutters something about not being ready for summer to be over before sinking into a chair at one of the workstations, putting in a set of earbuds, pulling a sheaf of papers from his briefcase, and commencing to type into the computer.  I don’t take the rebuff personally.  My outward affableness aside, I’m in a similar mood.

I typically feel a sense of loss as the fall semester begins.  I used to jump into the new year feet first with hope and anticipation, but now it’s with a sense of regret that maybe I hadn’t used the passing summer to better advantage. 

Like Jesse, my summer was as much work as vacation.  My academic year officially began ten weeks ago with an online summer class at Snowflake College.  This virtual class allowed me a couple of getaways which should have reinvigorated me, but it wound up with one of those incidents that have made me dread something I once loved.

Back in June, I was at once self-congratulatory and apprehensive.  The last academic year had been trouble-free, even pleasant.  There wasn’t a single troublemaker in any of my classes at any of my campuses.  Verdant Fields gave me a teaching award of my own last spring, albeit division level, and it assigned me an additional section for the fall.  I wondered how much longer my luck would hold.

Not for long, as it turned out.  There were 39 students in my summer online class at Snowflake.  Of those, 37 passed with a “C” or better.  One failed for not participating in the class after the first week.  The other neglected to submit any of the required writing assignments, which made up 1/3 of the coursework and therefore 1/3 of the final grade.

A week after final grades were posted, I get a panicked email from the latter student, whom I’ll call Devin.  Not surprisingly, Devin’s singing the blues.  He claims he uploaded all the writing assignments.  He said Whiteboard gave him a successful upload message each time.  He just can’t understand why the Whiteboard gradebook says the assignments are missing, he just can’t.  He’s transferring to Big State University, and I just have to give him a good grade.

Ah, to be young, lazy, and entitled!  Luckily for Devin, he’s just the kind of student Snowflake College nurtures.  And so, the following exchange ensued:

I answer Devin saying it was his responsibility to make sure the assignments were in. 

Devin replies that he meant to have them in, reminding me, with no proof of course, that he had uploaded all the work on time.  He closes with a gratuitous assertion that he doesn’t want me to think of him as a dishonest person.  (Too late for that, bud.)

I email Devin with a vague promise to look into available options, informing him that submitting late work for credit after final grades were in was, well, a trifle unlikely.

And then, silence.  For a day or two, anyway.  The next email missive came not from Devin but from Regina, the administrative assistant to our academic dean.  She informed me young Devin has submitted a grade change.

Now I’m beginning to see red.  In twelve years, no student has ever had the gall to challenge a grade I’ve issued.  I consult the Snowflake College faculty guidebook concerning the grade change policy.  My blood pressure ratchets even higher when I find that a grade change is issued only in cases of instructor error, bad faith, or incompetence.

I shot Regina a reply telling her in no uncertain terms that none of those criteria apply to my assessment of Devin’s efforts.  

Regina was unimpressed, though as a classified employee one can excuse her indifference to the spirit rather than the minutiae of academic regulations.  She answered with a tersely worded request to send her the corrected grade when ready.

The college allows a full year for grade changes after the end of term.  Young Devin is in for a wait.  While I’m sure I’ll catch no end of flak for dragging my heels, I plan to hold out against that lying little shit for as long as I can get away with it.  Screw him and the cayuse he rode in on.

If you’re unfamiliar with contemporary higher education, this story might seem confusing.  If you’re like me, you believed you got the grade you earned.  No more, no less.  So why is Snowflake College siding with a student who’s so obviously in the wrong?

Retention and completion rates, that’s why.  These are the excuse for any number of depredations committed of late by college administrators.  They will do anything to gain and keep students, even if it means condoning academic dishonesty and besmirching the motives and reputations of faculty.  (Well, the motives and reputations of adjunct faculty, anyway.)

We adjuncts have to take it because their jobs are secure, and ours are not.  Snowflake has been on an institution-wide quest to maintain enrollment and boost graduation rates in the face of a declining college age population in its service area.  In furtherance of this end, some clever grant writer managed to finagle a seven-figure dole to create a program to do just that.

Of course, any new program needs staff.  And so, Snowflake has created two new executive dean positions, touted as “temporary” even though everyone knows goddamn well they’re here to stay, to streamline its academic and job training programs.  And where you have administrators, you have to have a bevy of classified staff to do their bidding.

This push has been in the making for the past couple of years, supported by a public relations campaign to get faculty buy-in.  Last spring, the college even condescended to invite several part-timers, myself included, to brainstorm potential pre-packaged academic tracks for students who don’t know what they want to be when they grow up. 

We submitted our recommendations and were politely thanked by management.  A few weeks later, they released their initial plan.  It bore little resemblance to any of our recommendations.  I doubt if anyone bothered to look at them.

The implications for us in the trenches are grim.  We’re hanging on by torn and bleeding fingernails as courses and programs are cut or whittled down.  Meanwhile, the bureaucracy gets larger, or at least it’s holding ground.  No wonder Snowflake’s administration is so imperious.

They see themselves as the good guys, naturally.  More than few of them take pains to create rapport, or its simulacrum, at any opportunity. 

It doesn’t fly with me.  Nothing peeves me as much as a dean or vice president who rushes to point out that s/he too was once a part-time instructor.  I don’t care; the operative word in that statement is “once.”  We are not friends, and we have nothing in common.  I am labor; you are management.

The strange thing, and the saving grace, about the situation is that my best moments in the classroom and my successes in motivating students to learn still make up for any resentment and frustration.  There are lots of days when I find satisfaction and even pride in my work.  Sadly, those days are becoming fewer.  It’s like I’m locked in an abusive relationship where my abuser constantly reminds me of all the good times we had together to keep me from leaving.

Observing my friend Jesse, this sense becomes even more acute.  Finishing my prep work for next week, I try to wish Jesse a good day as I leave.  Engrossed with the computer monitor and lost in whatever sounds were coming through his earbuds, he doesn’t hear me.  I wave my hand in front of his eyes to get his attention.

Turning to me with a morose expression, Jesse merely nods.  I go away with a heavy heart.  Classes start Monday.



© 2017 The Unassuming Scholar

Sunday, March 19, 2017

As Seen on TV

Toward the end of last semester, I got an email from my department chair.  Well, not exactly from my department chair, whose messages are usually brief, often cryptic missives set from his iPhone. This email was a forward from a disgruntled applicant in the part-time faculty pool at Snowflake College.  Apparently, I was being asked to address his concerns.

The applicant wanted to know why he hadn’t been hired.  Reading the attached c.v., I learned his chief qualification was a master’s degree from a well-known online graduate program which is well known because it advertises on TV.  No classroom experience.  He once attended the state Republican convention as an observer.  He was a veteran who earned a Good Conduct Medal.  And that was about it.

I pondered the gentleman’s situation for a while, then wrote an answer choosing my words carefully so as not to offend.  I told him the academic job market was tight due to falling enrollment, and to seek other avenues to beef up his resume until things got better.  After clicking “Send,” I fretted that maybe I was a little condescending but he wrote me a rather gracious reply a few days later.

The incident got me to thinking.  As I’ve written in earlier posts, I’m not a fan of online education in general.  I look askance at those programs which advertise heavily.  So, I was gratified when Corinthian Colleges shut down a couple of years ago after years of investigation into its shady business practices, and was pleasantly surprised when ITT Tech abruptly ceased operations late last year. 

Our belief in our own shrewdness and common sense notwithstanding, we’re babes in the woods as consumers.  We will believe any claim as long as it’s stated authoritatively enough.  We’re told that studies beyond high school, which for most people means job training tarted up as “education,” is essential to getting ahead.   Public community colleges such as the ones I work for absorb much of the demand.  However, many folks can’t spare the time for in-person schooling due to work or family obligations.  That’s where the “virtual classroom” comes in.

Distance learning is an old idea.  Online classes are the latest manifestation of the correspondence course, which emerged in the late nineteenth century.  For generations, correspondence courses afforded its ambitious students the opportunity to learn everything from shorthand to TV repair to law.  Traditional universities had their own correspondence programs; living in a small rural town growing up it was common for people to take agriculture courses via our land grant university’s highly regarded extension program.  Britain’s Open University is considered a very successful experiment in affording higher ed to those excluded from it in the past.

Enrolling students who in an earlier time would never have considered college is big business.  P. T. Barnum would approve of the business model: Raise unrealistic expectations, take the money, then move on to the next bunch of suckers.  Speaking of P. T. Barnum, his latter-day incarnation faced controversy last fall when the revelation that Trump University had defrauded its students led the news for a couple of hours before the next lurid Trump tale took its place.  TU wasn't an online program, but it welshed on its implied promise that at least some of the proffered seminars would feature The Donald himself.  That particular example is an outlier, but many consumers are being sold a pig in a poke just the same when it comes to their postsecondary schooling options.

I suppose my sour attitude on this topic has been aggravated by the fact that I’m teaching an online course for the first time this semester.  It’s an honor on its face.  It’s a brand-new course, never before offered at Snowflake College, and I was given a free hand in its design and content. 

It’s not anything all that grand in practice.  The subject is the one in my discipline with which I have the least experience.  Except for a couple of hybrid classes which went dreadfully, I’d never taught anything but in-person lecture courses.

I got the job for two reasons.  The first is that my department has never seen me as the ideal public face of Snowflake College, in spite of consistently good student evals.  But they can’t force me out due to seniority and would prefer me to teach online as a consequence.  The second is that the new course is required for the transfer AA degree in the discipline but several of my colleagues already teach specialty courses they’d rather concentrate on instead of piloting a new one.  Since I like paying my bills and having a place to sleep, I accepted the assignment.

Its petty annoyances aside, I prefer the personal touch of an on-the-ground class.  I get to know my students as people instead of as names and email addresses.   My principal contact with the online students is to post brief comments on their discussion threads and written work and to troubleshoot the inevitable glitches with the LMS.  (These are more numerous and more consequential when the class is online than with in-person classes where I use the LMS mainly for posting study notes and grades.)  The absence of feedback in an online class is offputting for me.

Then there’s the odd cliquishness surrounding the distance learning people at Snowflake.  I took a preparatory training—online, of course—last summer.  We were hectored to drop our old-fashioned classroom personae.  We were informed in no uncertain terms that distance learners are different from those taking boring old traditional courses.  They don’t want a “sage on the stage,” we were told, they want a “guide by their side.”  The training was scattershot, but by August I felt ready to tackle the course shell.

Actually, I was ready well before that but the online programs director was out most of the summer due to a personal emergency and so did not create a shell until there were less than two weeks before the mandatory first review.  Add to that the fact I was creating course content from scratch and you can imagine how the first review went.  The evaluators, one a nutrition professor and the other a kinesiology ( ! ) professor, were not at all complimentary of my frantic efforts of the previous fortnight.  Much of it was nitpicking over the wording of certain passages in the syllabus and the absence of something they referred to as “instructor presence.”  Nutrition Proffie was especially scornful, concluding with a damning, “This instructor is not ready for the distance learning program.”  Ouch.

I pled for mercy with the program director who was partly to blame for the situation in the first place and got a re-review a few weeks later.  The course passed and now here I am.   Eight weeks in, and there have been only a couple of minor hiccups.  My fingers are crossed for the second half concluding successfully.

I’ve acquired a few insights concerning online classes based on my newfound experience.  Simply put, they’re a cash cow even for not-for-profit institutions like Snowflake College.  Once the 40-seat course was announced in January, it filled and waitlisted within days.  I was deluged with pleading emails from students desperate to add.  When the dust settled two weeks into the term, I still had 40 students but had experienced a turnover during the add/drop period of close to 20%.  When I read the discussion thread where I asked the students to introduce themselves, I learned nearly a third were not majors in the discipline at all despite the course being specifically intended for transferring majors.  No matter, they paid their fees, right?

Now we’re at the midpoint of the semester, a certain number have abruptly stopped submitting work.  A few more turn in stuff sporadically.  Several never attempted any work at all, which means I’ll have to cut them before the drop deadline so it won’t be my fault for their failing the class.  No matter, Snowflake College will keep their money anyway.

I’ll spend the next couple of months catering to the remaining, disembodied students who have persisted.  (Actually, a couple are students who took a class with me before whom I see around campus.  Even then, it’s hard for me to connect their online presence to our occasional real life interaction.)  I’ve been given my schedule for the next academic year.  I will be teaching the new course again in the spring.

Brick and mortar institutions benefit from e-learning because the ancillary costs are lower.  They still have to pay an instructor, true, but online classes reduce demand for physical facilities such as classrooms and offices, as well as saving on expenses for facilities maintenance, utilities, and campus security.  On the other hand, it creates opportunities for the burgeoning administrative class to advance their interests at the expense of students and the professoriat alike.

Back to the existential questions surrounding online instruction.  I’ll say what I’ve said numerous times on this subject.  For a growing segment of the public, higher education is a dumbed-down commodity hawked by cynical hustlers to take their money in exchange for goods of questionable value.  Even for the comparatively small number of students possessing the self-discipline to complete an online degree, the credential may not get them as far as they hoped.

Even in the much-maligned liberal arts, which do not have any immediately practical application and are thereby presumed to be readily communicable in the online format, distance learning has serious shortcomings.  Discussion threads facilitate peer-to-peer communication, but the asynchronous nature of the discussion hinder the sort of in-depth dialectical analysis of abstract ideas needed to foster critical thinking.  (Not that critical thinking is a skill particularly desired by employers, mind you, but I was always told that this was the lasting value of a liberal arts education.)   Real time classroom discussions are essential to an in depth understanding of the curriculum.

None of this is hinted at in the TV ads for University of Phoenix (the reigning king of nontraditional higher ed), National University (“national” despite U of Phoenix having greater market penetration), Southern New Hampshire University (my favorite—who knew tiny New Hampshire had an identifiable southern region?), and Grand Canyon University (for Christofascists wanting an online experience that won’t challenge them or their superstitions).  There are others as you know, but these are currently the worst offenders. 

I think of the spurned applicant from time to time.  How does a person lacking experience in mainstream academia but possessing the requisite paper qualifications break in let alone survive in a game whose nature he in no way understands?  It’s bad enough when your paper says you’re qualified in a particular field like my own where the economics of the game lead many well-qualified individuals to move on to more lucrative work.  But what if you have a degree in, say, nursing or clinical psychology without much (or any) field experience?  I’ve read of cases like these, where the students couldn’t find work in their chosen vocation and yet were stuck with crippling student loan debt.

Caveat emptor, some might opine.  The casualties of the education bubble are no different than those of the housing and tech bubbles before them.  The distinction is that while the previous market crises involved the relatively affluent and educated who should in fact have done their due diligence, the prey of the higher ed hucksters are more vulnerable and easily manipulated.  I doubt if this factored into their moral calculus, however. 

It’s just business, they’d say.  True, but it’s a shameful one,



© 2017 The Unassuming Scholar


  

Saturday, August 6, 2016

No Good Deed

You checked your messages after arriving home from a week out of town.  The first one hit you like a sucker punch to the solar plexus.

The message was from the dean’s administrative assistant at Snowflake College.  Specifically, it was from the executive dean’s office at the Quartz City campus.  Quartz City up until now had been the unblemished bright spot in your teaching itinerary.  The students are bright and inquisitive, and you get along great with your teaching colleagues and the classified staff. 

You are informed that Dean Stacy would like to meet with you in person to discuss an “incident” involving you several weeks ago while you were an evaluator at the Quartz City early college high school’s senior project presentations.  One of the other judges, a local community member, had made an allegation about you.  Please call back at your earliest convenience to schedule an appointment.

While you were expecting this, your heart sank nonetheless.  It has become the inevitable cost of doing business.  You’re good at your job, and although you are maybe a touch unconventional in your presentation most of your students like or are at least accepting of your teaching style.  You also are well aware that not everyone finds your personality appealing.  It even elicits hostility from a few individuals from time to time.  Your openness tends to leave you vulnerable to those whom you politely refer to as jerks and to people with issues.

Your accuser appears to straddle both categories.  You know what the charges are, since he pulled you aside after the first day’s presentations and told you what he thought.  (You are thankful that at least what he accused you of did not involve a student.)  Unnerved, you got away from the guy as quickly as possible and lay awake in bed most of that night trying to figure out what the hell had happened.  Before leaving campus that day, you made sure the school secretary scheduled you for a panel other than the one this son of a bitch would be participating in during the next day’s session.

You return to Quartz City the next day to find yourself beckoned into the principal’s office.  The principal, a dark, serious young man, informed you that an allegation had been made.  You deny it as a matter of course, a trifle annoyed by the principal’s condescending demeanor.   You have found through experience with your sons’ schoolteachers that many of them not only talk down to kids, but tend to do so with adults as well.  This gentleman seemed to have lost sight of the fact that you and your fellow college instructors are supposed to be the value added by an early college high school. 

The principal stiffly thanked you for volunteering your time after informing you ominously that he had to inform Dean Stacy of the allegation.  The rest of the day went mercifully well in spite of its awkward beginning.  Several of your former students shook your hand afterward, and introduced you to their parents.  They had heard great things about you and were glad to finally meet you.  One mom even told you her son had chosen your field as his major after taking your class. 

All this notwithstanding, the next couple of weeks were clouded by the accusation against you as you wait for the other shoe to drop.  Naturally, as all bad news seems to in your life, it fell when you were not quite at your emotional best.  In this case, the news arrived after you got home near midnight, jetlagged and facing the glum prospect of waiting all the next day for the airline to recover your inevitably lost baggage.

You call Quartz City the following morning, schedule your appointment with Stacy, and then spend the next couple of days rehashing events in your head trying to make sense of it all.  You consider yourself a man of integrity, and you become rattled and indignant whenever someone calls your character into question.  Your task now is to avoid appearing rattled and indignant.  However, your resentment festers.  Your family has had some degree of association with Snowflake College for nearly forty years.  You’ve taught for them for more than ten.  You gave your time freely and this is what happens?  You seriously consider never giving Snowflake another unpaid second of your time again.  You have already resolved privately to exclude the college foundation as a beneficiary of your will when you found out it had taken money from a certain real estate developer who has lobbied and worked to run public schools like private businesses.   Maybe you should just show up and just teach your scheduled classes from now on.

The distraction of your resentment notwithstanding when the day of the meeting arrives, you’re as ready as you’ll ever be.

Stacy, a tall, rather elegant woman around your own age, smiles warmly when you walk into her office, motioning you to a seat at a conference table.  You’ve never had a discussion with her beyond ordinary small talk, so you don’t know quite what to expect.

Stacy opens the discussion by coming right to the point: “So, tell me in your own words what happened.”

You take a deep breath and tell the story as calmly and clearly as you can.  You relate how you were seated next to your accuser at the first day’s panel.  You describe how, upon finding out the man was a former Marine you mentioned you were a veteran yourself.

“Oh, you’re a veteran!” Stacy exclaims.  “Thank you for your service.”  You smile awkwardly in reply. 

You never know how to respond to this, because thanking vets profusely for their service and describing them as “heroes” even if they were cooks or truck drivers or personnel clerks has become a social obligation of late.  You pride yourself on not having become what you call a “professional vet,” someone whose whole existence, like that of the high school football hero who never is able to recapture his past glories, centers upon that one fact in their lives.

Your accuser is just such a guy.  You’re all too familiar with the breed: overfed, loud mouthed, and jockeying constantly to be the alpha male in every situation.   He regaled you during the breaks between presentations with tales of his storied career as GI Joe with a kung fu grip, before his back gave out on him.  (If it isn't their knees, it’s their back.)  He tells you he’s active in the American Legion, AMVETS, the VFW, the DAV, and the rest of the alphabet soup of veteran’s organizations.  He tells you he served on the county veteran’s affairs commission.  He offers to help you upgrade your disability rating, a result that you know is between unlikely and impossible to achieve.  All the while your eyes are darting across the room looking for someone to catch your eye and rescue you from this blowhard’s narcissistic monologue.

Wincing slightly at the unpleasant memory, you continue your account.  You also point out your unblemished teaching record and your excellent classroom evaluations. 

Stacy, her head attentively tilted slightly to one side, pauses a beat before speaking.  “I see.  You know we have to take these allegations seriously, even if they’re unfounded.  Principal Nathan investigated and could not find any evidence against you.”

“That’s good to know.”

“Yes, and when I called the man—”  Stacy laughs slightly, then continues, “and I don’t even remember his name—“

“That’s all right.  I do,” you reply with a wintry smile.

Stacy goes on, “Anyway, he wasn’t very convincing and some of what he said contradicted what Nathan had told me.”

“That’s because it didn’t happen.”

“I’m sorry about all this.  In any case, since it occurred while you were off contract no mention of this incident will go into your personnel file.”

“That’s a relief.”

“You know, we really value the efforts of adjuncts like you.  Did you know I started out as an adjunct?”  Yes, you know.

The conversation wends on for a few more minutes before petering out.  At the end comes something you don’t expect.  As Stacy shakes your hand before you leave, she thanks you for coming in.  Then she says,

“Please don’t let this incident discourage you from volunteering with Snowflake College in the future.”

While you reply with a smile and a nod, a solitary thought runs through your mind:

Never again.  No fucking way.




© 2016 The Unassuming Scholar

Saturday, January 23, 2016

Loops & Boomerangs, Jedi & Trogs: Thoughts of a Freeway Flyer

Inservice training week is over.  Convocation came and went.  And I can breathe somewhat easier now that all my scheduled classes are a go for Spring semester.  Now all there is is the nervous anticipation of what to expect when I return to work on Monday.

The latter part of the semester break found me in a kind of groove.  (A groove for me is like a rut, just not as dismal.)  We’ve had a let-up from the constant snow we experienced since before Thanksgiving, and the sunlight through the windows has been a most welcome sight.   I’ve spent my days cooking soups and stews for sustenance and catching up on my writing. 

The past weeks have had a pleasantly monotonous quality, the house quiet as I sit at my desk tapping away at the keyboard.  When I needed company, I would play “Feel It All Around” by Washed Out on an endless loop.  When that no longer appealed to my ears, I’d play The Beta Band’s “It’s Not Too Beautiful” instead. Or perhaps Eric Reed’s instrumental version of “An Englishman in New York,” interspersed with “Poinciana” by Ahmed Jamal.

I’m going to miss this peaceful interlude.  This week’s trainings included a department meeting, where I was pleased to learn that Snowflake College was going to tackle the problem of declining enrollment by borrowing a page from the for-profit vocational “colleges.”  The counseling staff would plan a student’s curriculum from start to finish with a goal of finishing up within two to four years.  (We are, after all, a two-year college.) 

At first, this was good news.  A plan!  Administrators actually providing leadership!  Why, the president had gone to the length of appointing a task force to tackle the challenge! 

Then came the details.  In order to place students on predictable schedules, the times of day courses are to be offered will be “rationalized.”   In other words, general ed courses will be offered mainly in the morning and early afternoon while major or career training-specific classes will be offered primarily in the late afternoon and evening.  That didn’t faze me, until the other shoe dropped.

Paradoxically, it wasn’t the move toward making students ready for the local workforce that was the bad news.  Rather, it was the plan’s effect on the four-year transfer students which got everyone’s attention.  Permit me to set up the background: My discipline is in the social and behavioral sciences.  The “service course” my department provides for gen ed fulfills the same transfer requirements of the state unis in our region as a similar course in one of the humanities departments.  Students may choose a two-course sequence in the humanities or mix-and-match one course each from both departments.

The cannibalization of enrollment this overlap already causes is a problem for my department.  And for me.  Treetop, my “home” campus, which programs its own schedule, often places my section(s) on the same day and time block as the other department’s sections.  The campus administration is quite open about its preference for the instructor of the competing course, so I get shafted by them pretty regularly.  What I didn’t know before attending the department meeting is this is a reflection of attitudes in Snowflake’s administration as a whole.

Matt, our chair for this academic year, a bespectacled fellow about my own age with a dry sense of humor, explained that our department’s offerings weren’t included in the gen ed course package planned for the initiative.  Almost in passing, he added a colleague had mentioned that an unnamed administrator had suggested that our department, even its gen ed course, were unnecessary and that the humanities folks could do the job we’ve been doing.

Matt’s words were met first with disbelief, than with a clamor to identify the administrator.  Anita, our department’s only other tenured professor, a lady with a strong personality and a well-earned reputation for getting things done, promised she’d get to the bottom of this and raise some Cain in the process.  We part-timers murmured among ourselves as to what the implications would actually be.

We needn’t have asked.  Each of us knew the score.  The existential threat for us adjuncts is now two-fold.   If the rumor is true, we won’t jockey about to get class assignments anymore because the assignments will be nonexistent.

This isn’t what I bargained for ten years ago when I got an out-of-the-blue email from my graduate advisor telling me Snowflake College needed a last minute hire to teach a class.  I’ve covered the good, the bad, and the ugly of the adjunct’s life in this blog.  But it just seems the stakes for survival in this trade have gotten dicier as time goes on.

I have my own private narrative for what I do.  As a “freeway flyer,” a part-timer who divides his time among several campuses and institutions, I’m struck by the variations in students and institutional cultures.  I’ve even come up with a taxonomy not only for my classes but my commutes.  Days where I start from home in Treetop, teach at one campus (or two if the evening brings me back to home campus) are “loops.”  Days where I drive to Verdant Fields Community College, forty miles to the east of home then double back on my tracks to teach at Snowflake’s Quartz City campus, which is fifty miles west of home, are “boomerangs.” 

Boomerangs can be particularly stressful.  Last spring I taught six sections.  Three out of four of my instructional days were boomerangs.  That semester I drove 550 miles per week.

This semester, all my days will be loops.  But that still leaves the question of the kind of students I’ll have.  All my sections are day sections, which means even at VFCC many of them will be traditional four-year transfer students.  Even then, I know the personality of each section will vary.  The section whose students show the best attitude and aptitude will be my “Jedi class.”  (I’m not a Star Wars fan; I just made the label up on the spot one day and the kids were really pleased when I called them that.)  The section I find most trying is my “Trog class.”  (As in “troglodyte.”  I don’t share this appellation with them.)  I’ve had very few semesters where I haven’t had one of each.  

The colleges themselves have their strong and weak points.  Snowflake pays better than VFCC.  On the whole, Snowflake students are better prepared for college work.  Despite its large size, VFCC has a sterling support staff for adjuncts who do their utmost every day to make sure we instructors have what we need.   The administration at VFCC is fairly supportive of teaching staff, whereas at Snowflake, as you may have gathered already, the higher ups tend to be autocratic.  (There are exceptions—the folks at the Quartz City campus are wonderful.)   If only I could combine the best elements of both and eliminate the long drives, I’d be content.

In the meantime, I hope for the best even when this is getting ever more elusive.  Now, if only that flutter in my stomach would just go away…



© 2016 The Unassuming Scholar 

Friday, August 28, 2015

Vicious Circle

I had an epiphany today.  It occurred to me that as an adjunct professor I actually have something in common with corporate CEOs: Employment and pay aren’t necessarily tied to job performance.

The first week of classes went very well.  Three sections full and about half a dozen students seeking to add each of the other two.  I met with my last section of the week yesterday afternoon and went to my office to catch up on administrative work.  Opening my email I saw that the top message was from Matt, my department chair at Snowflake College.  The subject was simply titled “spring” [sic].

The message wasn’t what I expected to read.

From: Matt (chair@snowflake.edu)
Sent: Thursday, August 27, 2015 1:50 PM
To: Unassuming Scholar (scholar@snowflake.edu)
Subject: spring

Hello,

I hope that all is going well.  I am working on the schedule for next semester and was wondering which Quartz City section you prefer - day or night.

Things had been going well—until now.  As happens so often when I get messages from administrators and chairs my heart leaped into my throat. 

Here’s a little background so you will understand my problem.  I teach at two institutions on three different campuses.  Snowflake is a multi-campus institution covering a large geographical area.  I live more than eighty miles from the main campus where Matt and the other profs in my department work.  For the last several years I have been the sole instructor in my subject at my “home” campus in Treetop, a resort town in the mountains, and at the Quartz City campus in the foothills roughly sixty miles away.

Although I am the least senior part-timer in my department, even after nearly a decade of employment, no one based at the main campus is willing to make the long drive into the hills to take sections at Quartz City and Treetop thus giving me a de facto monopoly.

Or so I thought.

From: Unassuming Scholar (scholar@snowflake.edu)
Sent: Thursday, August 27, 2015 2:01 PM
To: Matt (chair@snowflake.edu)
Subject: Re: spring

Hello Matt...Is there someone else teaching at Quartz City next semester?

The answer came a few minutes later:

From: Matt (chair@snowflake.edu)
Sent: Thursday, August 27, 2015 2:05 PM
To: Unassuming Scholar (scholar@snowflake.edu)
Subject: Re: spring

We are in the process of looking at adding some part time faculty and Quartz City would be an option.  In the past we have had two folks up the hill, which gives us some safety should we lose and instructor and it gives students so [sic] diversity.

I was puzzled and slightly disturbed by that last comment.  I told myself that he meant giving students a choice of instructor rather than being stuck with just me but it didn’t help.

I pondered my options, staring at the computer screen momentarily paralyzed with anxiety.  I remembered a remark the Quartz City campus executive dean (not to be confused with the Executive Dean from Hell at the Treetop campus) made last week during a faculty in-service meeting.  She said that the demographics of the Quartz City area were changing and that Quartz City was transitioning from a predominantly evening campus to a day campus. 

I replied:

From: Unassuming Scholar (scholar@snowflake.edu)
Sent: Thursday, August 27, 2015 2:27 PM
To: Matt (chair@snowflake.edu)
Subject: Re: spring

I understand the reasoning, though I clearly would prefer both QC sections.  Treetop has me tentatively scheduled for TR 4:00-5:20, which means it probably won't make enrollment.

If I have to make a choice the TR 12:30-1:50 section would be the best fit.

The next volley landed in my inbox shortly thereafter:

From: Matt (chair@snowflake.edu)
Sent: Thursday, August 27, 2015 2:50 PM
To: Unassuming Scholar (scholar@snowflake.edu)
Subject: Re: spring

Hi,

Interesting.  Patty sent a rollover indicating that it was taught 2:30-3:50 last Spring.  I imagine that they will cling to that section (regardless of the time) to the bitter end in Spring - they do not want to lose course offerings entirely.

We will list the night course as staff and see what develops; we might need you to take it on in the end.  It all depends.  But I hope to clear up the uncertainty as soon as possible.

Best wishes

Yep, clearing up the uncertainty would be pretty frickin’ great.  Going over the message a second time I found myself wondering about Matt’s odd practice of omitting his correspondent’s name from the salutation and his own from the closing.  I was also confused by the lack of precision.  Was “it” a section at Quartz City or Treetop?  “It” didn’t match the schedule I’d been on at either campus any time lately.  The Executive Dean from Hell’s administrative assistant at Treetop is named Patti, so maybe that’s the campus he meant.

From: Unassuming Scholar (scholar@snowflake.edu)
Sent: Thursday, August 27, 2015 3:01 PM
To: Matt (chair@snowflake.edu)
Subject: Re: spring

Hi Matt,

Last spring I taught a Monday evening section at Treetop.  Believe it or not, that class filled and ran a wait list.  This semester, nothing.   I don't know if it's scheduling or just the fickle nature of student demand on a small campus.

If you are referring to QC, all the TR afternoon sections I've taught there from Fall 2012 forward have met at 12:30.

I'll try to keep my dance card open Weds. evenings just in case.

Thanks,

Unassuming Scholar

I sat slumped in my desk chair, utterly deflated.  It’s been a day and I still feel this way. 

I honestly don’t understand why the department chair wants to scale back my workload.  For all the heartburn I’ve had with Treetop’s EDFH, my department has been great to work with.  Unlike Verdant Fields, my other institution, adjuncts participate in scheduled department meetings and our input is solicited on student learning outcomes for each course we offer, whether our institutional objectives are being met, best teaching practices, etc.  It’s all very collegial and an exception to the norm for part-timers elsewhere.  Until yesterday I honestly (and I guess naively) believed I was a valued member of the team.

It can’t be my performance.  It just can’t.  My last classroom evaluation was a year ago and it went swimmingly.  Matt solicited the students’ input while I was out of the room, which was provided along with the very positive write up of the visit.  Not a single negative comment from the class.  I even got an “attaboy” note from our associate dean.

That’s why the decision hurts so much.  I know I complain a lot in these pages about lazy, entitled students and self-interested administrators but I thoroughly enjoy the act of teaching.  Sure, I have my off days like anyone.  But when I’m in the “zone,” when the students are engaged by what I’m saying and every single one of them is hanging on my every word, it’s the best feeling in the world.  It is the closest experience I have to love in my life and it is painful to me when any of it is taken away.

Now I’m on tenterhooks awaiting my fate.  Treetop will continue to toy with me, and Snowflake’s part-time seniority system is the only thing keeping me on staff.  Not that EDFT wouldn’t jump at the chance to show me the door.  The funny thing is that she doesn’t know me well even though she’s been in her position for nearly seven years.  I got on great with her predecessor, but EDFH and I have never even had a proper conversation.   The only conclusion I’ve come to is she formed an immediate and irrational dislike of me at first sight.  One factor in her dislike is that I think my appearance and manner clash with her idiosyncratic vision for the campus.  The executive deanship at Treetop campus is a platform for EDFH’s vanity and she wants nothing or no one to contradict her viewpoint.  Unless I can outlast her, which I doubt, I’m basically screwed.

I still haven’t heard about spring term from Daniel, my department chair at Verdant Fields Community College which is located in a neighboring state 35 miles from Treetop.  The pay at VFCC is uniformly lousy with no seniority or benefits.  But Daniel has consistently assigned me the maximum allowable three sections per semester for years.  (Another plus of VFCC is that the support staff in every single office and department I’ve encountered have been without fail friendly and helpful toward part-timers.)  But Daniel warned me over the summer that he might not be able to offer me three sections for spring.  Our former academic dean is from our department and he returned to the classroom this year, reducing the number of sections available for part-time faculty.  That reasoning I can understand even though I still wish to have three sections.  Besides, the ex-dean is an established authority in his field…and he is a great guy to boot.

Meanwhile I’m trying to calm my nerves.  I worked with a much smaller teaching load for years and still got by financially.  My oldest son is an adult now and I’m not paying support, which eases some of my money problems.  I’ve built up my savings the last two years.  I tell myself it could be worse.

And that is the problem, particularly at Snowflake.  A smaller load slows my accrual of further seniority and salary step increases.  Snowflake faculty participate in our state’s public school teacher retirement fund which requires the equivalent of five years’ full-time employment to vest.  Fewer classes mean I have to work more years to be eligible for retirement.  (By contrast VFCC is in a Right-to-Work state.  It’s “retirement” system consists of mandatory contributions to a 457 fund.)

I do not know how much longer I can keep at this.  I have a small pension from my earlier career but the income stream doesn’t cover even my modest lifestyle.  My younger son, to whom I am obliged to pay a monthly allowance while attending college, turns 22 in a little more than five years ending my financial responsibility for my family.  I had hoped to have enough money put together by then to retire from teaching and moving to an expat-friendly country such as Mexico or Belize to live.

That looks much less likely now.  Course load reductions can send a part-timer into a vicious spiral.  As his teaching income shrinks, the adjunct has to look for supplemental income or give up teaching altogether to stay afloat.  The thought of leaving the classroom is hateful to me.   It is an integral part of my identity, and I am too old to begin again at something else.  I don’t want to do anything else.  This is my calling.

If only the people I work for understood this.  Unfortunately for me I am only another wheel in the machine to them.   

I guess that’s what I am.  Expendable.

I think I will crawl into a bottle of bourbon this weekend.  There doesn’t seem to be much else left to do.



© 2015 The Unassuming Scholar 

Monday, August 17, 2015

An Inauspicious Start

It’s a full week before classes begin and my schedule has already begun to shrink.

An email at the top of my inbox this morning: The sender is The Executive Dean from Hell.  This can’t be good.  It isn’t.

Among her many gifts she is apparently psychic.  With eight days to go before the first meeting of my Tuesday-Thursday afternoon section she’s pulled the plug.  It was at 85% of our institution’s minimum retention threshold. 

Really?  More than a week to spare, and there was no possibility of getting two or three more students to enroll?  As if students never sign up for classes at the last minute?


At least this time she wrote she was “sorry”…



Saturday, November 1, 2014

Professor Scholar's Responses to Common Student Questions and Excuses


Please read the syllabus.

I’m sorry you are unwell and can’t make it to class.  Feel better.

No, I don't have a stapler.

You don't know when the research paper is due?  Check the announcements section on the LMS.  Or consult your syllabus.

Did you miss anything while you were out last week?  No, I don't think so.  We held a moment of silence to mourn your absence, and then I wasted time for the next three hours.  Just like I always do.

Your grandmother passed away last night?  I'm very sorry for your...Wait a minute.  Didn't your grandmother die the second week of class?

When's the exam?  I don't remember offhand.  Check the syllabus.

Yes, we are having class Thanksgiving week.

You're going to Acapulco next week for a much needed vacation?  That's great, but we're still having the exam.  No, you can't make it up.

No, I don't have a stapler.  Didn't you hear what I said to the student in front of you?

So, you say the Dean is a family friend, huh?  Perhaps she should be more discriminating about who she associates with.

Your family is coming in early for the holidays and you have to miss class.  Not my problem.

I'm quite aware that your mom / dad / significant other / dog thinks you're special.  I happen to think you're a lazy, entitled oxygen thief and a waste of a valuable classroom seat.

Do I have a stapler?  What do I look like, that Milton guy in Office Space?

If you think I'm mean and unfair, just wait until you have a boss.

No, I don't have a goddamn stapler!

Because fuck you, that's why!



 © 2014 The Unassuming Scholar

Friday, November 29, 2013

Thankfulness

You’re burned out already.  You don’t normally feel this way until at least mid-March.  But this semester has been particularly trying.  You only feel a slight relief at the prospect of a few days off for Thanksgiving.

About half of your Wednesday evening section bothers to show up.  While you expected this, it galls you nevertheless.  Not even having a writing assignment due this week was enough to pull them in. 

You find their logic for missing a whole week’s material baffling.  And they’re not the only ones; the campus has been a ghost town all week.  Basically, these students have decided to parlay a single-day celebration into a seven-day weekend.  These are the same kids who, in a couple of weeks, will angrily demand to know why they’re not getting an A in the course.

Those “knowledge explorers” who have deigned to attend walk up to your desk to hand in their papers.  Inevitably, half of them will bring loose leaf papers to you and ask if you have a stapler.

“No, I don’t have a stapler.  Just like I didn’t have one the last time you asked.  If you can afford that new iPhone you’re always playing with in class, you can afford basic school supplies.  Like a stapler.”

Karen is at the front of the line.  Karen’s a cheerful young lady who brightens the classroom on those days she decides to show up.

“Here’s my paper, Mr. Scholar!  See, I stapled it this time!”

“That’s great, Karen.  Thank you.”  Karen doesn’t move along.  “Is there something you want to tell me, Karen?”

Karen hesitates, then chirps, “I can’t stay!  My grandparents are coming from out of town for Thanksgiving!  I’m so excited I couldn’t pay attention anyway!”  She consoles your obvious disapproval by placing a cupcake on your desk.  “I baked these today!” she gushes.  “See, it has a smiley face on it!”

“That’s very thoughtful of you, Karen.  I’ll see you next week.”

“Oh, I knew you’d understand!  Happy Thanksgiving!”  With that, Karen traipses happily out the door.  Hers will be the only holiday wishes you’ll receive from your students.

Jonah shuffles up next, dressed despite the cold weather in his customary athletic shorts and sleeveless T-shirt.  Jonah is a stocky boy with a head of closely-cropped black bristles that remind you of a porcupine’s quills.  “Mr. Scholar?”

“How may I help you, Jonah?”

“Uh, I scratched my eye today.  I have…pinkeye.  And I lost one of my contacts.  So, I won’t be able to stay in class, you know?”

Yes, you know.  “Okay, Jonah.  It’s up to you.  See you next week.”

Jonah disappears.  You hear a grunt from the figure lurking over your left shoulder.  You turn.  “Yes, Toby?”

“Uh-h-h-h-h…Jacob can’t make it tonight.  Family gathering.  Here’s his paper.”

Jacob Feldman is the skinny, garrulous little shit who sits in the dead middle of the front row, like Toby one of the gifted and talented kids from the high school.  You’re privately relieved to be deprived of his company this week.  You only wish Toby had decided on getting an early jump on the holiday as well.

Six thirty rolls around.  You peer balefully at the smattering of students scattered among the room’s empty seats.  You call for their attention.

“Okay, let’s get started.  Thank you all for honoring me with your presence this evening.”

Toby clears his throat and raises his hand.  “Yes, Toby?”

“How come we’re having class tonight?  It’s Thanksgiving.”

“Thanksgiving’s tomorrow.”

“But all my other classes were cancelled this week.  Even the important ones like yoga and macramĂ© weaving!”

“And your point is…”

“Dean Kimpossible said professors could cancel class this week.”

“Dean Kimpossible isn’t teaching this class.”

“Kimpossible is a family friend,” scowls Toby.  You wonder if Toby’s dad is the kind of guy who says he knows the chief of police to get out of a speeding ticket.  Probably.

“We’re having class, Toby.”  You notice a strained tone creeping into your voice as the vivid image of waylaying this entitled little prick after class and bashing his brains in flashes through your mind.   This is worrisome; normally the homicidal fantasies don’t kick in until about February.  “Of course, you’re free to leave if the idea offends you.”

Toby replies by deepening his scowl as he slouches down further in his chair.

“Great!  Let’s get started,” you say with an enthusiasm you haven’t felt since the first week of the semester (and really not even then).

About ten minutes in, the door opens and Claire scurries inside.  Claire is another of the high schoolers, a slight, dark-haired girl who speaks so rarely that for a while you suspected she was mute.  Her quietude is her best quality, one for which you are willing to excuse her tenuous relationship with punctuality.

“Hi, Claire.  Thanks for stopping by.”  Claire manages a faint, strained smile as she takes a seat in the back. 

As class drags on, you ponder on the hard-won education you worked so diligently for, paying your way with a string of lousy minimum wage jobs and still graduating in four years, prevailing despite the skepticism (and sometimes outright hostility) of your poor, culturally stunted, and intellectually benighted family.  You think back on your anticipation each semester of studying even subjects outside your major, even the general ed classes nobody liked, and you remember feeling privileged having the chance to learn them.

You contrast this with the worldview of your own students.  The affluent kids attending Snowflake accept college as a given in their lives, just another stepping stone toward an inevitable future of material abundance and smug complacency.  You’re not sure whether they’re better or worse than the troglodytic proles jamming the classrooms at Verdant Fields, who were suckered by its marketing hook that the education it purports to offer will magically transform their dreary lives no matter how dimwitted and unmotivated they may be.

Meanwhile, the customary fifteen-minute mid-class break has failed to bolster spirits…theirs or yours.  Unable to bear the morose stares of your charges any longer, you opt to end class a half-hour early.  You tell yourself that it’s for your own convenience and not theirs, but it’s undoubtedly mutual.  Suddenly energized, they rise from their seats and begin pushing towards the door.

You hear a grunt from the figure lurking over your left shoulder.  You turn.  “Yes, Toby?”

“Uh-h-h-h, I won’t be here next week.”

Like I actually give a crap, you think.  “All right, Toby.  The final is the week after.  You’ll need to be here.”

“Okay-y-y-y…”

“Bring a Scantron form and a #2 pencil.”

“Okay-y-y-y…”

“Goodbye, Toby.”

Toby mumbles unintelligibly and ambles out the door.  You catch sight of another student in your peripheral vision.  Claire silently hands you her paper with a tentative, crooked smile.  Naturally, it’s unstapled.

“Thank you, Claire.”  You try your best to sound sincere and somehow manage to pull it off.  Claire follows Toby out the door without a word. 

Inside of a minute, the classroom is empty but for you. You savor the stillness for a brief moment, shuffle papers into your briefcase, and turn off the lights as you exit.   

Walking to your car, you promise yourself you won’t even look at their papers until Monday.

© 2013 The Unassuming Scholar