Tuesday, May 21, 2013

I Am the Law, So I Won

Even as the news arrived that former Argentinian dictator Jorge Rafael Videla had died in prison, we learn that his contemporary counterpart in Guatemala, Efraín Ríos Montt, may go free after that country’s Supreme Court overturned his genocide conviction and ordered a partial retrial.[1]

Ríos Montt, one may recall, ruled Guatemala during the most vicious period of its long-running civil war during the early 1980s.  His staunchest ally was the United States; President Reagan praised him as a “man of integrity” committed to “social justice.”

The kind of social justice Ríos Montt promoted in Guatemala was, shall we say, very selective.  Even the CIA expressed concern over the mounting death toll as US- and Israeli-supplied and trained troops took the lives of numerous civilians in such atrocities as the Plan de Sanchez Massacre.  Although the campaign against URNG guerrillas took center stage and was used to justify excesses in the name of establishing “democracy,” Ríos Montt’s administration pressured poor farmers and indigenous Mayans to give up their support for the guerrillas and pledge their loyalty to the state.

The result was a swath of destruction which put Billy Sherman’s March to the Sea to shame, with hundreds of villages razed.  The population escaping death in the attacks was left homeless and bereft of means of subsistence.   Now, more than thirty years later, Ríos Montt faces at least the possibility of being held accountable for his actions.  As his case returns to trial, we (and his thousands of victims) should be cautiously hopeful for a just outcome.  But, while times have changed for the better throughout Central and South America, we must also remember that having been the law for so long, these aging military rulers expect, and too often receive, a large measure of deference from their civilian successors.   

Don’t be surprised when Ríos Montt goes free.


© 2013 The Unassuming Scholar



[1] Apparently, the Supreme Court upheld the conduct of and the evidence submitted at the trial through April 21st, but quashed subsequent proceedings.

No comments:

Post a Comment