Sunday, September 2, 2012

Bright Profs, Small Campus (A Bad Parody of a Popular 1980s Novel)


In honor of my fellow adjuncts who are returning to work over the next several weeks, I humbly offer this small diversion…

You are not the kind of guy who would be at a place like this during the last week of summer break.  But here you are, and you cannot say the terrain is entirely unfamiliar, although the past three months have made the details fuzzy.

The summer has already turned on that imperceptible pivot where Memorial Day weekend changes into the few short days before classes begin.  You know this moment has come and gone, but you are not yet willing to concede that you have crossed the line behind which all is the pleasure of a long vacation and beyond which is the anticipatory palsy of knowing you must soon face classrooms full of slack-jawed freshmen.  Somewhere back there you could have cut your losses, but you rode past that moment when you signed your contract for the fall semester. 

You are seated at a small desk in a big room filled with your colleagues.  The occasion is the semiannual faculty meeting at Snowflake College.  You glance idly at your fellow faculty as they saunter in.  Most of them are locals who live in Treetop.  You can easily identify the profs who commute from out of town.  They’re the ones who aren’t dressed like mannequins in an REI store.

The seats around you fill up quickly.  You nod to Jan as she takes the desk in front of you.  Phil, the business professor, takes the seat to your immediate right.  You like Phil; he’s a decent sort.  Duckie grabs the seat to your left.  Duckie is an affable fellow, particularly popular with the young female students despite his diminutive stature and uncanny resemblance to Jon Cryer.  He also has the grating habit of punctuating every third sentence or so with a rapid fire, staccato chuckle.  You alone seem to have noticed this tic.  You have no particular reason for disliking him that you can put your finger on, but you do anyway.  Despite this, you make small talk as you wait for things to start.

Like a conductor tapping her baton on a lectern, Dean Kimpossible clears her throat.  Everyone looks up.  The meeting begins.

Kimpossible is a stout, fortyish blonde who in unguarded moments wears a hard, vaguely pissed off expression.  In conversation, she affects a calculatedly empathetic air.   You have deduced from her various public pronouncements that her philosophy is mainly a pastiche of bumper sticker aphorisms such as “Not all who wander are lost,” grafted onto odd bits gleaned from Esalen, est, and Gestalt therapy, by way of 1970s Marin County.    

Kimpossible holds a doctorate in Wiccan mythology from an online degree mill, of which she is inordinately proud.  She has been the campus dean for the past four years, but likes to burnish her street cred by teaching at least one section a semester.  She is well-liked by most of your peers.  Your stomach churns at the very sight of her.  You are normally tolerant of flakes, but a flake with an agenda scares the living hell out of you.  You fidget uncomfortably in your cramped plastic chair.  

“Hello, and welcome to our staff meeting.” 

Kimpossible clasps her hands before her and tilts her head slightly to one side.  “Please forgive me if I’m not one hundred percent tonight.  I’ve experienced a family crisis over the past couple of weeks.  My beloved Schnauzer, Fritz, suffered an intestinal blockage.  He nearly died.  Twice!  But I called upon the Earth Goddess to guide the veterinarian’s hands and heal Fritz, and She answered me by making Fritz whole again and in harmony with the cosmos.”  Everyone around you murmurs sympathetically.  Kimpossible acknowledges their approbation by nodding slowly and softly saying, “Thank you, thank you.”

You settle in resignedly as Kimpossible covers the same stale topics you have heard at numerous staff meetings.  You surreptitiously check your watch every few minutes.   You shift and shift again in your seat, trying in vain to get comfortable.  The hard plastic of the chair gradually numbs your posterior.  You regret having had that second bowl of black bean vegetarian chili at the pre-meeting potluck.  

As the dean chatters on, you desperately seek a diversion.  You stare transfixed at the back of Jan’s head and the mass of long, stringy hair spilling over the back of her peasant blouse.  Jan teaches Vedic meditation three times a week.  This is a very popular class at Snowflake.  Clearly, there are few experiences more gratifying than sitting crosslegged on your very own mat with forty other people in a large circle, chanting “Om” in unison for fifty minutes at a stretch while earning college credit. 

Your path and Jan’s ordinarily do not cross.  Regrettably, this has not always been the case.  Your Monday evening section last fall had the misfortune of meeting in the same room as Jan’s afternoon class.  You soon discovered that Jan, carried away by the rapture of communing with the life force of the universe, invariably ran over her scheduled class time leaving you and your students waiting in the hallway. 

You suffered in silence for a couple of weeks.  You wanted to be a team player.  You did not want to make waves.  You learned the custodial staff was not nearly as magnanimous as you.  They complained to Kimpossible about having to set up desks in the room after Jan’s class to accommodate yours. 

You were disappointed but hardly surprised to learn that, in the face of this dilemma, Kimpossible made a perfectly logical decision: Rather than tell Jan to wrap things up on time, she moved your class into a stifling broom closet of a room downstairs over your bitter protests.  Your students blamed you for their discomfort.  They swore they would take Vedic meditation the following semester.        

After what seems an eternity, Kimpossible gets to something resembling a point: “Tonight, we’re going to discuss how we evaluate our students and keep them engaged.  Remember, Snowflake College is like no other college and our students are unique.”

You groan inwardly.  You think, oh god, here it comes.

“First, I want to talk to you about the ways we measure student progress.  Sometimes you just can’t rely on A’s and B’s alone to show students how much having them in your class means to you. 

“I’m also aware that a few of the less enlightened among you are demoralizing students with C’s, D’s, and F’s when you know that all of them did their best and many of them have always been ‘A’ students.  This has to stop!

“Let me give you an example of positive reinforcement that you can use in your classrooms.  When Fritz was clinging to life in the pet hospital, a technician came in to draw blood.  He tried, he really tried, but he just couldn’t get the needle into a vein. 

“Fritz was howling in pain, and I could see that the technician’s self esteem was affected by this.  So I patted him on the arm and said, ‘That’s okay.  You did your best.  That’s all that matters.’

“You should have seen his face!  He brightened right up!  He still couldn’t find a vein, but the important thing is he gave it his best effort and he felt good about himself afterwards.  We must make sure our students feel good about themselves, too!

“Now, I’d like you to share your student engagement strategies with the group.”

You sense an opportunity to shine.  You raise your hand.  Kimpossible frowns.  “Yes, Unassuming?”

“Well, I like to assign small group work—“

Kimpossible sighs and cuts you off impatiently.  “We don’t have time for a story, Unassuming.  How about you, Duckie?”

“In my classes, I give them small group work.  I find that keeps them engaged.  Because, you know, they need to be engaged, right?  Huh-huh-huh-huh-huh!”

“Oh my gosh!  You are so right, Duckie!  No wonder your students love you!  How about you, Jan, what do you think?” 

“I really believe in kinesthetic learning,” Jan says breathily.  “Only by moving around can students get in touch with their inner spirit and fully appreciate the beauty that is the world.”

“True, so true, Jan!” Kimpossible pauses for effect, then continues: “These are all great points. 

“We have to adapt our teaching style to keep our students’ attention.  I’ve decided to start with this fall’s Mavens & Intuitions series.”  Mavens & Intuitions is Snowflake’s monthly community speakers program.  You have attended several events in the past.  You found them interesting and informative.  You find that Kimpossible felt otherwise.

“I don’t like lectures!” Kimpossible proclaims.  “Lectures are boring!  They’re only good for communicating useful information efficiently.  People should learn stuff that’s fun!  That’s why Mavens & Intuitions this year will be about entertainment and doing things people enjoy.

“In the same spirit, I expect all of you to make your classes a truly enriching experience for our exceptional students.  Have a blessed semester!”

At last, the meeting is over.

You leave the building and practically sprint for your car.  You sink into the driver’s seat and take a deep breath.  The smell of the surrounding pine forest envelops you.  The thought of tonight’s meeting and the prospect of teaching another collection of entitled brats sticks in your throat and you almost gag.  You will have to go slowly.  You will have to learn everything all over again…

Then again, maybe you won’t.

© 2012 The Unassuming Scholar 

Friday, August 24, 2012

American as Cherry Pie

Another week, another shooting.  It’s like background noise by now. 

In New York City, a disgruntled former employee shot and killed his boss this morning.  Several news reports indicate that the NYPD wounded several bystanders firing at the gunman as he tried to make his escape.  Collateral damage, I suppose.  The main thing is they got their man, right?

Just part of the zeitgeist, it seems…         

Saturday, August 18, 2012

Tall Poppies

This has been a banner week for civil liberties.

Julian Assange continues to sit in the Ecuadoran embassy in London, fending off extradition to Sweden to face manufactured sexual assault charges so that he can be extradited in turn to the United States to stand trial for embarrassing its leaders.

Meanwhile, in Russia, the three members of the anarcho-punk feminist collective Pussy Riot have been sentenced to two years in prison for running afoul of the Russian Orthodox Church and Vladimir Putin.  The church has forgiven them.  Mr. Putin has not.   

A case of tall poppies being cut down?


Thursday, August 16, 2012

So Many Yahoos, So Few Houyhnhnms

More tragedy this week.

This time it was a gunman shooting and wounding a security guard at the Family Research Council headquarters in Washington, D.C.  The fact that the target was a right wing organization and that the assailant briefly argued with the guard over the FRC’s homophobic politics has brought out trolls of all stripes on the Yahoo! News website.

I probably shouldn’t pay attention to readers’ comments on online news items.  Too much time on my hands, I suppose, though the impending start of the fall semester will surely take care of that.  Meanwhile, I’ve uncovered a malignant trove of comments on the FRC shooting story.  A typical gem reads, “Thanks, Obama, for emboldening gays.”  Many others are simply unrepeatable. 

Several threads ask if the shooter is going to face hate crime charges, with a few comments making the risible claim that liberals are violent and should not be trusted with guns.  I also had a good laugh at the posts linking the incident with Occupy Wall Street.   True to their penchant for reductionist thinking, the wingnuts on Yahoo! have conveniently lumped their sundry liberal and progressive bugbears into a single, inchoate target for their bile.   

Rather than make a keening plea for greater civility on the Interweb, I will dig in my heels and answer back. 

A number of Yahoo! posters complained that liberal tolerance is a double standard.  It’s clear that these people equate the desire for tolerance with moral weakness or, worse, a willingness to passively suffer abuse.  (This is not a baseless claim—Jonathan Rieders’ sociological study of working class, conservative whites in the Brooklyn neighborhood of Canarsie during the 1970s found that many of them associated liberalism with masochism.)  In other words, gays and lesbians and their sympathizers should be glad to take any maltreatment their stronger, more masculine brethren dish out.  This is a dangerous assumption.  The truth is that if a particular group of people are singled out and pushed around long enough, a few of them are going to push back.  Not every member of a marginalized minority is going to subscribe to the ethos of Gandhi or King.

There is also the very strong possibility that maybe, just perhaps, the gunman wasn’t so much making a political statement as he was answering his inner demons.  I won’t speculate on what troubled the FRC assailant.  It may well be the same pathology that infected the movie theater and Sikh temple murderers.  Or, it could be something even more inscrutable.  Not every violent act has to have meaning. 

Finally, the political right has no one to blame for the erosion of civility but itself.  The so-called class war that conservative pundits accuse their opponents of waging was begun not by liberals or progressives (two distinct political species conservatives frequently conflate) but by this country’s moneyed elites.  It’s a simple matter of divide and conquer: Divert attention from substantive issues such as corporate fraud and political manipulation by scaring workers into believing that what little ground they still hold is being lost.  

The unwashed foot soldiers for the 1% are an ideologically reliable mass, unswayed by the evidence around them that the system is riddled with rot.  Instead, they worry about taxes on wealthy “job creators” who in fact export jobs and secret their wealth in the Caymans, about nonexistent plots to take their guns or drive God out of their lives, and about “illegals” and “welfare queens” receiving unearned “handouts” from government programs. 

Conservative media act as an echo chamber that amplifies popular resentments.  Rush Limbaugh, Glenn Beck, Ann Coulter, Bill O’Reilly, et al., engage in agitprop to divert their audiences’ ire from its rightful targets.  It is little surprise that they have come to shape and define the political discourse, and we are all the poorer for that.  What we need in our national dialogue are more Houyhmhms and fewer Yahoos.


© 2012 The Unassuming Scholar



Tuesday, August 14, 2012

More Real Email…

From:  James <birkenstock_ boy@umail.com>
Date:  Friday, August 10, 2012 8:12 AM
To: Unassuming Scholar <scholar@snowflake.edu>
Subject:  burning man

hi unassuming,

my name is james i will be attending your class this upcoming sumester. however my friend has given me a burning man ticket. the dates for the festival are aug 27 to semtember 4. i see that the dates conflict with the start of school. i am wondering if it is imparitve that i attend these first few days?   

please contact me back.

your student james


From:  Unassuming Scholar <scholar@snowflake.edu>
Date:  Friday, August 10, 2012 12:37 PM
Subject:  Re: burning man

Hi James,

Congratulations on scoring tickets to Burning Man.

Concerning your classroom attendance, it’s not up to me to manage your time.   However, you miss class at your own risk.  All lecture material is testable, and you cannot make up missed work except under extenuating, documented circumstances such as accident or illness.

Cordially,

Unassuming Scholar


From:  James <birkenstock_ boy@umail.com>
Date:  Friday, August 10, 2012 7: 28 PM
To: Unassuming Scholar <scholar@snowflake.edu>
Subject:  RE: Re: burning man

ok, cool!  i ll email you pictures from the playa!

--j

© 2012 The Unassuming Scholar

Friday, August 10, 2012

It’s a Meaner World

The past several days have brought more bad tidings in the aftermath of the Colorado theater massacre.  This time it was an attack on a Sikh temple in Wisconsin by a white supremacist.  Meanwhile, Jared Lee Loughner, the Arizona gunman who killed a federal judge and wounded then-congresswoman Gabrielle Giffords, as well as killing or injuring several bystanders, has pled guilty in order to escape trial and a possible death sentence.  Atrocity blurs into atrocity as weeks and months drift by, jumbling together in the popular consciousness.

And these are just the big events that get widespread news coverage.  Every community in the country suffers less lurid tragedies on a fairly regular basis.  Even as I write this, a local news station is covering a the story of local man who, for whatever unreason that wormed its way out of a feverish brain, has taken his kids hostage and barricaded himself in his home.

Violence, of course, is a commonplace in our cultural lives, as “American as cherry pie,” as H. Rap Brown memorably put it.  (That Brown is serving a life sentence for murder gives his truism all the more credibility.)  Gratuitous violence is apparently a historical pastime, being part and parcel of such patina-tinged myths as Old West outlaw John Wesley Hardin shooting a man for snoring.  Violence is the language of the rugged individualist who must answer his challengers, of loners who face a hostile environment in the same way America must face a hostile world.  

As with other art forms, film mirrors the culture that produces it.  With its emphasis on visual patterns to tell a story, film is particularly conducive to communicating graphic violence.  Add to this gradual decline of narration in mainstream American film since the 1970s brought on by our growing dependence on sundry electronic media.  The multiplicity of distractions has undermined our ability to follow complex (or multiple) plotlines.  And so the art of American film has come full circle: The narrative conventions established by D. W. Griffith in The Birth of a Nation have given way once more to fleeting images meant to leave emotional impressions rather than tell a story.  

Conventional narrative, then, is becoming a thing of the past, sacrificed to moviegoers’ short attention spans.  To attract paying audiences, most successful mainstream films in the past decade have relied on varying formulae of CGI effects, comic book characters, improbable stunts and pyrotechnics, fart jokes, and teens or twentysomethings hooking up.  Films with actual storylines and fully developed characters are relegated to art houses.  It’s not terribly surprising that the Colorado theater shootings took place at a screening of The Dark Knight Rises; in fact, the one thing that James Holmes and his victims seem to have had in common was execrably bad taste.

While bad taste is common, it’s not universal.  The occasional gem does make its way onto the big screen. The debasement of human relationships—of human decency—in contemporary America is the theme of Bobcat Goldthwait’s dark comedy God Bless America, which melds the sensibilities of Joel Schumacher’s Falling Down with those of Mike Judge’s Idiocracy with shades of Taxi Driver thrown in for good measure.  The middle aged protagonist (a sad-eyed Joel Murray) has had enough of the narcissism and incivility of the people around him and goes on a killing spree against entitled reality TV stars, loudmouthed conservative pundits, would-be pedophiles, and double-parkers.  Our antihero is joined by an equally disaffected teen, a sociopathic Manic Pixie Dream Girl (Tara Lynne Barr) who becomes the Bonnie to his Clyde.  God Bless America climaxes in a hostage standoff on the set of an American Idol-style talent show, with the ill-starred couple falling in a fusillade of police bullets on national television as the screen fades to black.

Goldthwait’s satire is unnervingly spot-on, to the point where I visibly winced at the sight of Murray’s character gunning down a bunch of teens chattering on cell phones in a movie theater screening, of all things, a documentary on the My Lai massacre.  Fiction mimics fact mimics fiction, seemingly ad infinitum.  The verisimilitude of film is intensified by the emotional impact of real life events.

It also gives new life to the chicken-and-egg riddle of whether mass media images trigger violence or are merely reflect an already violent society.  Movie violence has been accused of inspiring copycats for decades.  The 1974 “Hi-Fi murders” in Ogden, Utah were inspired by a scene in the Clint Eastwood movie Magnum Force in which a pimp exacts revenge on a wayward hooker by forcing her to drink a bottle of Drano.  John Hinckley was driven to shoot President Reagan by the exploits of Travis Bickle, Robert DeNiro’s character in Taxi Driver.  Occasionally movies are influenced in turn by real events, as in the case of Sidney Lumet’s Network evoking the actual on-air suicide of Florida TV newswoman Christine Chubbuck. 

The 1990s saw a surge in movie and TV copycats.  Natural Born Killers has been cited as the model for several teen spree murders, including the Columbine massacre.   The subway tollbooth arson scene in Money Train is said to have prompted an actual firebombing of a New York City tollbooth.  Even MTV’s cartoon series Beavis and Butthead was implicated in the case of a small child who set a fire in imitation of one of its characters. 

Arguably, media violence is catalyst rather than cause; folks predisposed to violence merely need an excuse to do wrong.  However, this and similar theories, such as the purported link between pornography and sexual violence, suffer from weak causality.  Although I’m loath to draw a parallel with the claim, “guns don’t kill people, people kill people,” the motive to harm comes from within.  When violence becomes an internalized social norm, it is bound to inspire individuals to employ it as a first and last resort.  It’s still a mean world, regardless of whether it’s on celluloid, in digital, or in the flesh.  Expect it to remain so until our values change for the better.

© 2012 The Unassuming Scholar




Thursday, August 9, 2012

No Consequences

It's just come out that the U.S. Department of Justice has declined to bring charges against Goldman Sachs or its employees for their role in the financial meltdown.

As if we needed another reminder that we have the best government money can buy…